Fitbit Charge 2: Sleep Tracking Accuracy Explained

Sleep quality is an essential component of health, and wearable devices like the Fitbit Charge 2 offer a convenient way to monitor sleep in a home environment. Fitbit devices use an accelerometer and optical photoplethysmography (PPG) to measure bodily accelerations and blood flow, respectively, to determine sleep stages and quality. While Fitbit Charge 2 shows promise in detecting sleep-wake states and sleep stage composition, particularly REM sleep, its accuracy has been questioned, especially in distinguishing light sleep (N1+N2) from deep sleep (N3). Fitbit's sleep staging algorithm may introduce discrepancies, and its accuracy is context-dependent, with a reported 69% accuracy in any given 30-second time window. For best results, it is recommended to wear the device snugly and higher on the wrist. While Fitbit provides valuable insights, it should be noted that it is not a medical device, and for serious sleep issues, consulting a healthcare professional is advised.

Fitbit Charge 2 accuracy compared to polysomnography

The Fitbit Charge 2™ is a consumer multi-sensory wristband that can be used to measure sleep/wake state and sleep stage composition. Polysomnography (PSG) is a widely used method for measuring sleep that involves using many bodily sensors, including EEG, to determine if a person is in N1, N2, N3, REM, or awake.

A study published in Chronobiology International evaluated the performance of the Fitbit Charge 2™ against PSG in measuring sleep/wake state and sleep stage composition in healthy adults. 44 adults aged 19-61 (26 women and 25 Caucasian) participated in the study, which was conducted at the SRI Human Sleep Research Laboratory. The participants were screened to be free from mental and medical conditions, and the presence of sleep disorders was evaluated with clinical PSG. PSG findings indicated periodic limb movement of sleep (PLMS, >15/h) in nine participants, who were analyzed separately from the main group (n = 35). PSG and Fitbit Charge 2™ sleep data were compared using paired t-tests, Bland-Altman plots, and epoch-by-epoch (EBE) analysis.

The results of the study showed that the Fitbit Charge 2™ had a sensitivity of 0.96 (accuracy to detect sleep), a specificity of 0.61 (accuracy to detect wake), an accuracy of 0.81 in detecting N1+N2 sleep ("light sleep"), and an accuracy of 0.49 in detecting REM sleep. Overall, the Fitbit Charge 2™ showed promise in detecting sleep-wake states and sleep stage composition relative to PSG, particularly in the estimation of REM sleep, but with limitations in N3 detection.

Another study compared the Fitbit Charge 2 with PSG in adults with obstructive sleep apnea (OSA). This study found that the Fitbit Charge 2 showed acceptable sensitivity but poor specificity. The study concluded that consumer sleep trackers still have insufficient accuracy for clinical settings, especially in clinical populations.

In summary, the Fitbit Charge 2™ appears to have reasonable accuracy in detecting sleep/wake states and sleep stage composition relative to PSG, but it may not be accurate enough for clinical use. Further studies are needed to fully validate the accuracy and reliability of the Fitbit Charge 2™ in different settings and populations.

Fitbit's sleep staging algorithm

Despite these limitations, Fitbit's sleep staging algorithm can still provide reasonably accurate mean values of sleep and heart rate estimates, especially under naturalistic conditions. It can give valuable feedback on your sleep, helping you adjust your sleep schedule to get more rest. For example, you may realize that you sleep closer to seven hours when you go to bed at 11 pm and wake up at 7 am, instead of the expected eight hours.

Fitbit's accuracy in measuring sleep quality

Fitbit's sleep tracking function is a useful feature for users who want to gain insight into their sleep quality and patterns. The Fitbit Charge 2, in particular, has been the subject of various studies that examined its accuracy in measuring sleep.

One notable study compared the Fitbit Charge 2 with polysomnography (PSG), the gold standard for sleep measurement, in a group of 44 healthy adults. The results indicated that the Fitbit Charge 2 had an overall accuracy of 0.96 in detecting sleep, with slightly lower accuracy in identifying wakefulness (0.61), N1+N2 sleep (0.81), N3 sleep (0.49), and REM sleep (0.74). These findings suggest that while the device can provide valuable insights into sleep patterns, there are also limitations to its accuracy, especially in distinguishing between different sleep stages.

Another study conducted on shift workers, including police officers and paramedics, found that the Fitbit Charge 2 demonstrated better specificity than sensitivity. It showed higher accuracy for WASO (0.82) and REM sleep (0.86) compared to N1+N2 (0.55) and N3 sleep (0.78). Additionally, the study revealed potential limitations in the staging algorithm, as the distribution of sleep episode durations differed between the Fitbit and PSG.

A user who tested the Fitbit Versa over two months also noted that the device provided valuable feedback on their sleep patterns and helped them adjust their sleep schedule. They highlighted the importance of wearing the device snugly and higher on the wrist for more accurate readings. However, they also suggested that Fitbit could improve its communication about the accuracy of its sleep staging, which was reported to be around 69% accurate in any given 30-second time window.

In summary, while Fitbit devices, including the Charge 2, can offer valuable insights into sleep quality and patterns, they may have limitations in accurately distinguishing between different sleep stages. Users should refer to the provided data as a general guide and be mindful of potential variability in the accuracy of sleep staging. Nonetheless, Fitbit's sleep tracking function can still help users develop a better understanding of their sleep habits and make informed adjustments to improve their sleep hygiene.

Fitbit's accuracy in measuring sleep quantity

Fitbit fitness trackers and smartwatches have a robust sleep-tracking function. The Fitbit Charge 2™, for example, has been evaluated for its performance in measuring sleep/wake state and sleep stage composition in healthy adults. The results showed that the device had an accuracy of 0.96 in detecting sleep, 0.61 in detecting wakefulness, 0.81 in detecting light sleep, 0.49 in detecting deep sleep, and 0.74 in detecting REM sleep. Another study found that the Fitbit Charge 2 can provide reasonably accurate mean values of sleep and heart rate estimates in shift workers under naturalistic conditions.

The accuracy of Fitbit in measuring sleep quantity may vary depending on various factors, such as the specific model, the individual's sleeping patterns, and the way the device is worn. For example, the Fitbit Charge 5 has been reported to be "finicky" in recording sleep stages, with factors such as the tracker's placement or the user's sleeping position potentially affecting its accuracy. Additionally, it is important to note that the accuracy of sleep staging data may be less crucial than the overall quantity of sleep. Unless you have serious sleep problems, your body generally does a good job of allocating the total amount of sleep across the various stages.

To optimize the accuracy of sleep tracking with a Fitbit device, it is recommended to wear the device moderately snugly and higher on the wrist, approximately 2-3 finger widths above the wrist bone. This positioning ensures that the device can accurately capture physical movement, pulse rate, and breathing patterns, which are used to infer the stage of sleep. Additionally, wearing the device on the non-dominant wrist may be more comfortable and less likely to disrupt sleep.

It is worth noting that Fitbit devices that do not measure heart rate may not provide information about sleep stages. However, they can still track the overall quantity of sleep, which can be valuable for understanding your sleep patterns and making adjustments to your sleep schedule. Additionally, while Fitbit devices can provide insights into your sleep quantity and quality, they should not be relied upon for medical diagnosis or treatment. For specific sleep-related concerns, it is always recommended to consult a healthcare professional.

Fitbit's accuracy in measuring sleep heart rate

The accuracy of Fitbit's sleep heart rate tracking is influenced by factors such as personal physiology, device placement on the arm, and the activity being performed. Fitbit devices use optical heart rate sensors that emit green LED lights to detect changes in blood volume in the wrist's capillaries. These sensors can classify sleep stages with 69% accuracy in any given 30-second time window, according to a 2017 paper published by Fitbit scientists. This accuracy level depends on context, and the sleep staging is only correct slightly more than two-thirds of the time, which is not explicitly communicated to users.

A naturalistic study compared the Fitbit Charge 2 with polysomnographic (PSG) measures in a shift-work population of 59 first responder police officers and paramedics. The Fitbit Charge 2 showed better specificity than sensitivity, with higher accuracies for WASO (0.82) and REM sleep (0.86) than for N1+N2 (0.55) and N3 (0.78) sleep. The Fitbit heart rate displayed a small underestimation of 0.9 beats per minute (bpm) and struggled to capture sudden HR changes due to lower time resolution. The study concluded that the Fitbit Charge 2 can provide reasonably accurate mean values of sleep and heart rate estimates for shift workers under naturalistic conditions with careful data processing.

Another study found that nonsleep-staging Fitbit models tended to overestimate total sleep time (TST) and sleep efficiency (SE) while underestimating wake after sleep onset (WASO). These models achieved accuracy values between 0.81 and 0.91, sensitivity values between 0.87 and 0.99, and specificity values between 0.10 and 0.52. Recent-generation Fitbit models that use heart rate variability and body movement to assess sleep stages performed better than early-generation nonsleep-staging models.

The Fitbit app provides a Sleep Score, which takes into account the time asleep, the amount of time spent in deep and REM sleep, and restoration, which is influenced by sleeping heart rate and resting heart rate. Fitbit's sleep-staging feature, introduced in 2017, is now incorporated into various models, including the Fitbit Charge 2, Charge 3, and Versa. This feature uses a combined body movement and heart rate variability (HRV) algorithm to estimate time spent in different sleep stages.

While Fitbit's sleep tracking function has its limitations and potential biases, it can still provide valuable feedback on sleep patterns and overall sleep quality. It is important to note that the accuracy of sleep staging data may be less critical than understanding the total amount of sleep one gets.

Frequently asked questions