Ronaldinho's Adventures: Snakes And Sleep Stories

'Don't Sleep, There Are Snakes' is a book by linguist and author Daniel Everett, detailing his experiences living with the Pirahã people of the Amazon. It offers a unique insight into the language, culture, and spiritual beliefs of this indigenous group, challenging our understanding of what it means to be human.

Everett, a former missionary, travelled to the Amazon intending to convert the Pirahã to Christianity and translate the Bible into their language. However, he discovered that the Pirahã had an incredibly unusual language, which did not fit into any existing linguistic theories. The Pirahã have no counting system, no fixed terms for colours, no concept of war, and no personal property. They live entirely in the present and value first-hand experiences above all else.

Everett became obsessed with the Pirahã language and its cultural and linguistic implications. Over three decades, he spent a total of seven years living with the Pirahã. His experiences with them caused him to question his faith, and he eventually lost his belief in the God he had hoped to introduce to the tribe.

The book is part passionate memoir, part scientific exploration, offering a life-changing tale that challenges our understanding of language, thought, and life itself. It is a fascinating account of a small tribe of Amazonian Indians in Brazil, providing a window into their world and a completely different way of life.

The Pirahã people's unique language and culture

The Pirahã people are an indigenous group of hunter-gatherers living in the Amazon Rainforest in Brazil. They are the sole surviving subgroup of the Mura people, with a population of around 700-800 individuals. They live along the banks of the Maici River, a tributary of the Amazon River, in Humaitá and Manicoré in the state of Amazonas. The Pirahã call themselves the Híaitíihi or Hiáitihí, roughly translated as "the straight ones".

The Pirahã language is the indigenous language of the Pirahã people and is considered one of the most phonologically simplest languages known. It has a very small phoneme inventory, with only 10-13 phonemes, and a high degree of allophonic variation. The segmental phonemes include consonants such as /ʔ/, /b/, /ɡ/, /s/, and /k/, and vowels that can be nasalized after the glottal consonants /h/ and /ʔ/. The Pirahã language also has at least two phonemic tones, which can be marked by an acute accent or left unmarked.

One of the most notable features of the Pirahã language is the absence of numerals and grammatical number. There are no words for precise numbers, but rather concepts for a small amount and a larger amount, such as "hói" and "hoí". The language also lacks grammatical distinction between singular and plural, even in pronouns. This has led to claims that the Pirahã language provides evidence against linguistic relativity and universal grammar theories proposed by Noam Chomsky.

The Pirahã people have a unique culture that is solely concerned with matters that fall within direct personal experience. They have a simple kinship system that includes terms such as "baíxi" for parent, grandparent, or elder, and "xahaigí" for sibling. They also value no coercion and have no formal leaders, resulting in a social system similar to other hunter-gatherer bands.

The Pirahã are highly skilled at ensuring their survival in the jungle. They have extensive knowledge of plants and animals in their area and can navigate the jungle with ease. They take short naps throughout the day and night and rarely sleep through the night, as they believe that sleeping less helps to "harden" them. They build simple huts and create tools such as bows and arrows, scraping implements, and loosely woven palm-leaf bags. They also trade Brazil nuts, wood, and sorva (rubbery sap used in chewing gum) for consumables or tools.

The Pirahã have no concept of a supreme spirit or god but do believe in spirits that can take on the shape of things in their environment, such as jaguars, trees, or people. They also have a unique way of communicating, as they can whistle their language, which is how Pirahã men communicate when hunting in the jungle.

In recent years, there have been attempts to introduce Western culture to the Pirahã community, including the opening of a school where they learn Portuguese and mathematics. However, the Pirahã remain monolingual and resistant to adopting new ways of life, preferring to maintain their unique language and culture.

The Pirahã people's lifestyle and beliefs

The Pirahã people are an indigenous group of Amazonian Indians in central Brazil, the sole surviving subgroup of the Mura people. They are hunter-gatherers, living mainly on the banks of the Maici River in Humaitá and Manicoré in the state of Amazonas. As of 2018, they number 800 individuals. The Pirahã call themselves the Híaitíihi or Hiáitihí, roughly translated as "the straight ones". They call any other language "crooked head".

The Pirahã are incredibly skilled at surviving in the jungle. They know the usefulness and location of important plants, understand the behaviour of local animals, and can walk into the jungle naked and walk out three days later with baskets of fruit, nuts, and small game. Their culture is concerned solely with matters that fall within direct personal experience, and thus there is no history beyond living memory. They have a simple kinship system and no social hierarchy or formal leaders.

The Pirahã language is unique, unrelated to any other extant tongue. It is based on just eight consonants and three vowels, with a complex array of tones, stresses, and syllable lengths. This means that Pirahã speakers can dispense with their vowels and consonants and sing, hum, or whistle conversations. It is an incredibly difficult language to learn, and until Daniel Everett and his wife, Keren, arrived in the 1970s, no outsider had succeeded in mastering it.

The Pirahã have no counting system and no fixed terms for colour. They have no concept of war or of personal property. They live entirely in the present and have no creation myths or origin stories. They do believe in spirits that can sometimes take on the shape of things in the environment, such as jaguars, trees, or people.

The Pirahã people have resisted Western culture and capitalism. They have no interest in the Bible or Christianity, and have rejected attempts to teach them farming. They do, however, trade Brazil nuts and sex for consumables or tools such as machetes, gunpowder, powdered milk, sugar, and whiskey. They also trade rubbery tree sap used in chewing gum for soda-can pull-tabs, which they use to make necklaces to ward off spirits.

In recent years, the Brazilian government has installed a modern medical clinic, electricity, and television in the Pirahã community, and a school has been opened where the Pirahã learn Portuguese and mathematics.

The challenges of learning the Pirahã language

The Pirahã language is spoken by the Pirahã people of the Amazon basin in Brazil. It is one of the most challenging languages to learn, with only a few hundred speakers and a very small number of linguists with field experience in the language. The challenges of learning the Pirahã language are detailed below:

• Phonemes and Phonology: Pirahã has one of the smallest phoneme inventories of any known language, with as few as ten phonemes, and a high degree of allophonic variation. This makes it difficult to distinguish different sounds and identify the correct pronunciation.
• Lack of Counting System and Numbers: The Pirahã language lacks a counting system and specific words for quantities like "one" or "two". Instead, they use relative terms like "a few" and "more". This makes it challenging to learn for those accustomed to numerical systems.
• Absence of Abstract Color Terms: The Pirahã language does not have fixed terms for colors other than "light" and "dark". This can be challenging for learners who are used to distinguishing and naming specific colors.
• Simplicity and Lack of Complexity: Pirahã is considered one of the phonologically simplest languages, with a basic kinship system and a limited clause structure that does not allow for nested recursive sentences. Its grammar is agglutinative, using affixes to communicate grammatical meaning.
• Cultural Constraints and Immediacy of Experience: The Pirahã culture constrains communication to non-abstract subjects within the immediate experience of interlocutors. This means that Pirahã grammar and language are closely tied to their way of life, which can be challenging for learners from different cultural backgrounds.
• Lack of Recursion: Pirahã sentences do not contain recursion, or the ability to embed clauses with new information within sentences. This is a significant challenge for learners accustomed to languages with recursive structures.
• Evidentiality and Cultural Influence: Pirahã has evidentiality suffixes that indicate the speaker's source of information, such as hearsay, observation, or deduction. This cultural aspect of the language requires learners to state their sources of information explicitly, which can be a unique challenge.
• Pronunciation and Intonation: The Pirahã language can be spoken, whistled, hummed, or encoded in music, with consonants and vowels sometimes omitted and meaning conveyed solely through variations in pitch, stress, and rhythm. Learning the correct intonation and non-verbal aspects of communication can be difficult.
• Limited Exposure and Field Experience: The Pirahã people have avoided cultural dilution and maintained their distinct language. This has made cross-language comparisons and learning opportunities extremely limited, adding to the challenge of acquiring the language.

The impact of the Pirahã people on Everett's life

In his book, *Don't Sleep, There Are Snakes: Life and Language in the Amazonian Jungle*, Daniel Everett details his experiences living with the Pirahã people in the Amazonian jungle. Over three decades, Everett spent a total of seven years with the Pirahã, and his account of his time with them is an exploration of language and an anthropological investigation.

The Pirahã people had a profound impact on Everett's life. Firstly, their language defied all existing linguistic theories. Everett became obsessed with their language and its cultural and linguistic implications. The Pirahã have no counting system, no fixed terms for colour, no concept of war, and no personal property. They live entirely in the present. Everett's interest in their language led him to question modern linguistic theory, specifically Noam Chomsky's theory of universal grammar. Everett argues that the Pirahã language does not allow for linguistic recursion, challenging Chomsky's theory.

Secondly, Everett's experiences with the Pirahã people caused him to lose his Christian faith. He arrived among the Pirahã intending to convert them, but their contentment and way of life made him question his own beliefs. He writes, "I would go so far as to suggest that the Pirahã are happier, fitter, and better adjusted to their environment than any Christian or other religious person I have ever known." Everett's interactions with the Pirahã people led him to realise that he no longer believed in God, and he eventually became an atheist.

Thirdly, Everett's time with the Pirahã people taught him about the relationship between language and culture. He argues that there is a close relationship between the two, and that language is a tool used to solve the common human problem of communication. Everett's experiences with the Pirahã people and their language led him to develop an alternative view to the idea that language is innate.

Finally, Everett's time with the Pirahã people influenced his view of human nature. In his book, *Dark Matter of the Mind: The Culturally Articulated Unconscious*, Everett reviews a range of academic disciplines to argue that humans are moulded by culture, and that the idea of human nature does not fit with the facts. He supports Aristotle's claim that the mind is a blank slate and argues that the most compatible notion of the self is the Buddhist concept of anātman.

The broader implications of the Pirahã people's language and culture

The Pirahã people are an indigenous community living along the Maici River, a tributary of the Amazon River, in Amazonas, Brazil. They are the only surviving dialect of the Mura language, with an estimated 250-380 speakers. The Pirahã language and culture have several implications, including:

• Phonology and Phonetics: Pirahã is one of the phonologically simplest languages known, with a small phoneme inventory. It has only 3 vowels and 8 consonants, one of which is a glottal stop. The language can be whistled, hummed, or encoded in music, with consonants and vowels sometimes omitted, and meaning conveyed solely through variations in pitch, stress, and rhythm.
• Numerals and Counting: The Pirahã language lacks a counting system and fixed terms for numbers. They have words for 'one' and 'two', distinguished only by tone, but these may actually mean "small quantity" and "larger quantity". They have no concept of cardinal or ordinal numbers, and their language does not allow for linguistic recursion. This absence of exact quantity language does not prevent the Pirahã from performing tasks that rely on numerical equivalence.
• Kinship: The Pirahã have the simplest kinship system of any human culture. They use a single word, 'baíxi', for both 'mother' and 'father', and they do not keep track of relationships beyond biological siblings.
• Colour Terms: The Pirahã language lacks abstract colour words, with only terms for 'light' and 'dark'.
• Time and Memory: The Pirahã live entirely in the present, with no creation myths or origin stories. They do not plan more than a day ahead and rarely talk about the future or distant past. They have no individual or collective memory beyond two generations.
• Material Culture and Possessions: The Pirahã have a very simple material culture, with few physical possessions. They do not store food and rarely talk about the future, focusing only on the immediacy of experience.
• Social Structure: The Pirahã have a very conservative culture, resistant to innovation. They have no leaders or hierarchy and treat children as equals, allowing them to learn through experience without parental orders. They are remarkably tolerant, peaceful, and non-violent, with no sense of envy or vengeance.

Frequently asked questions