Napping Vs Sleeping: What's The Best Rest?

is it better to sleep in small bits

Segmented sleep, also known as biphasic sleep, involves two sleep periods: a longer nighttime sleep and a shorter daytime nap. Some people naturally follow this sleep pattern and find that it works well for them, while others prefer monophasic sleep. There is historical evidence that biphasic sleep used to be the norm, and some people today continue to adopt it to increase productivity and reduce the effects of lost sleep. However, there has been limited research on the health effects of segmented sleep, and it may not be compatible with modern lifestyles that involve work and family commitments.

Characteristics Values
Name Segmented sleep, Biphasic sleep
Description Involves two sleep periods: a longer nighttime sleep and a shorter daytime nap.
Historical Evidence Humans used to naturally follow a biphasic sleep schedule.
Benefits May provide extra energy, may be more natural and work better for some people.
Drawbacks May cause social issues (missing evening events), potential impact on circadian rhythms due to artificial light at night, lack of research on long-term health effects.
Recommendations Consult a doctor before changing sleep schedules, maintain a consistent schedule, time light exposure, practice good sleep hygiene.

shunsleep

Segmented sleep is not a new idea

Segmented sleep, or biphasic sleep, is not a new concept. In pre-industrial times, it was common for people to wake up for a couple of hours in the middle of the night, according to historian Roger Ekirch. During this time, people spent their free time praying, smoking, having sex, or even visiting their neighbours before returning to sleep until morning.

A study by the National Institute of Mental Health supports this idea. Researchers found that when exposed to 10 hours of light per day (similar to a winter's day), participants got their sleep in two chunks, with a few hours awake in between. This sleep pattern is also observed in animals.

Some people in contemporary settings continue to adopt biphasic sleep to reduce the effects of lost sleep and maintain productivity. However, it is important to note that there is limited research on the health effects of segmented sleep. While some individuals find that it suits their lifestyle and provides extra energy, others may find it challenging to maintain a social life or adapt to the needs of a family and job.

If you are considering segmented sleep, it is recommended to consult with a doctor and create a consistent schedule that includes proper light exposure and good sleep hygiene.

Birth by Sleep: What You Need to Know

You may want to see also

shunsleep

There are mixed views on the safety of segmented sleep

However, there is limited research on the effects of segmented sleep on health. Clete Kushida, MD, PhD, the medical director of the Stanford Sleep Medicine Center, suggests that it is best to avoid segmented sleep unless there is a specific reason that requires one to sleep that way. He points out that there are many unknowns, such as the long-term safety of segmented sleep, and how age, medical conditions, and sleep disorders may influence its effects. On the other hand, Mary Carskadon, PhD, a sleep researcher at Brown University, states that she is not aware of any evidence that sleeping in two rounds at night causes health issues, indicating that it may be safe for those who naturally sleep that way.

It is important to consider the potential impact of artificial light on the circadian rhythm during the middle-of-the-night awake period. Carskadon recommends keeping the light dim at night and avoiding blue light, such as LED bulbs, which have the most significant impact on circadian rhythms. Additionally, while some people adopt a polyphasic sleep schedule, involving multiple naps throughout the day, Kushida cautions against this approach, emphasizing that adults need at least seven hours of sleep in 24 hours.

Overall, the limited research on segmented sleep suggests that it may be safe for some individuals, but there are still many unknowns. As sleep is essential to overall well-being, it is recommended to consult a doctor before making significant changes to one's sleep schedule.

shunsleep

The impact of artificial light on circadian rhythms

Light is essential for life, and artificial light has improved visual performance and safety. However, there is growing concern about the potential health and environmental impacts of artificial light. The availability of artificial light has significantly altered the light environment, especially during the evening and at night. This change in the light environment can increase the risk of developing circadian rhythm sleep-wake disorders (CRSWD), which are often caused by a misalignment of endogenous circadian rhythms and external light-dark cycles.

The human circadian pacemaker, the suprachiasmatic nuclei (SCN) in the hypothalamus, is synchronized to the 24-hour solar day via a pathway from the retina. The SCN acts as the master circadian clock, organizing daily recurring physiological functions such as hormone secretion and body temperature. The master circadian clock is synchronized by the light-dark transitions perceived by the eyes, but artificial lighting, especially at night, can disturb this process.

The effects of light on human circadian rhythms and sleep are mediated by the retina, which contains specialized photoreceptors called cones and rods. Cones are most dense in the centre of the retina (the fovea) and allow us to see colour, spatial detail, and motion at light levels typical of daytime. Rods, on the other hand, are suppressed during the day and only signal at light levels typical of twilight and darkness. While rods cannot distinguish colours, they are more sensitive and allow for better vision in low-light conditions.

Findings from several studies suggest that mistimed light exposure, including exposure to artificial light at night, disrupts the human circadian rhythm, potentially leading to further health impacts. For example, a study published in the journal PNAS found that people exposed to just 100 lux of light while sleeping had an increased heart rate compared to those sleeping in dim light (3 lux). This disruption to the normal cardiovascular pattern could have negative consequences for heart health. Additionally, the investigators found that light exposure during sleep increased the body's insulin resistance.

To mitigate the impact of artificial light on circadian rhythms, it is recommended to sleep with blinds shut and lights off. If light is needed while sleeping, it should be a dim light close to the floor, preferably with an amber colour, as this stimulates the brain less than white or blue light.

shunsleep

The benefits of a short, midday nap

While the idea of segmented sleep, or biphasic sleep, is gaining traction, it is important to understand the pros and cons before adopting it. Biphasic sleep involves two sleep periods: a longer nighttime sleep and a shorter daytime nap.

A short, midday nap can be beneficial for several reasons. Firstly, historical evidence suggests that humans used to naturally follow a biphasic sleep schedule, indicating that sleeping in two segments may be more aligned with our natural sleep patterns.

Secondly, a short nap during the early afternoon can improve overall well-being and energy levels. Taking a short break to rest can help reduce the effects of lost sleep and maintain productivity throughout the day.

Additionally, a midday nap can be especially useful if you need to stay up later than usual or if you have something important to do that requires you to be alert and focused. By taking a short nap, you can improve your alertness and cognitive function, ensuring you are more awake and attentive when needed.

Finally, some people find that biphasic sleep comes naturally to them and works great for their lifestyle. If you are one of those people, embracing a biphasic sleep schedule can help you optimize your sleep and make the most of your time.

However, it is important to remember that there is limited research on the long-term effects of segmented sleep, and individual results may vary. It is always a good idea to consult with a doctor or sleep specialist before making any significant changes to your sleep schedule.

shunsleep

The negative side effects of sleep deprivation

While segmented sleep may work for some people, there are potential drawbacks to this approach. The negative side effects of sleep deprivation can be significant and have wide-ranging impacts on the body and mind.

Firstly, sleep deprivation can disrupt the central nervous system, impairing the body's ability to send and process information. This can lead to difficulties with concentration and learning, and coordination, increasing the risk of accidents. It can also affect decision-making abilities and creativity, and in extreme cases, cause microsleep, where individuals fall asleep for a few seconds without realising, which can be dangerous if they are driving.

Secondly, sleep loss can negatively impact emotional well-being and mental health. It can cause irritability and mood changes, and emotional distress, as well as increase the production of stress hormones. Sleep-deprived individuals may feel more impatient and prone to impulsive behaviour.

Thirdly, insufficient sleep can weaken the immune system, making it harder for the body to fight off illnesses and increasing vulnerability to respiratory infections and other diseases. It can also negatively impact heart health and metabolism, increasing the risk of cardiovascular disease, heart attack, and stroke.

Finally, sleep deprivation can disrupt hormone production and affect appetite-regulating hormones, leading to weight gain and an increased risk of obesity. It can also cause insulin resistance and impact blood sugar management, which can have long-term consequences for health.

While the effects of segmented sleep require further research, it is clear that sleep deprivation can have serious negative consequences on overall health and daily functioning. Therefore, it is essential to prioritise getting adequate, uninterrupted sleep whenever possible to mitigate these risks.

Frequently asked questions

Segmented sleep, also known as biphasic sleep, involves two sleep periods: a longer nighttime sleep and a shorter daytime nap. In pre-industrial times, it was normal to get up for a couple of hours in the middle of the night.

Some people find that segmented sleep feels natural and works well for them, providing extra energy. However, there is a lack of research on the effects of segmented sleep on health, so it is recommended to avoid it unless there is a specific reason for adopting this sleep pattern.

Artificial light in the middle of the night can disrupt your circadian rhythms, so it is recommended to keep the light dim and avoid blue light from LED bulbs. Additionally, adults need at least 7 hours of sleep in 24 hours, so ensure you are getting adequate total sleep.

If you want to experiment with segmented sleep, start by creating a consistent schedule, timing your light exposure, and practicing good sleep hygiene. You can also try a 20-minute nap during the early afternoon to ease into biphasic sleep. Consult with your doctor before making any radical changes to your sleep schedule.

Written by
Reviewed by
Share this post
Print
Did this article help you?

Leave a comment