Exploring Rem Sleep Deprivation: Study Design Strategies

REM sleep, or rapid eye movement sleep, is a distinct stage of sleep that occurs in four to six short cycles throughout the night. It is characterised by increased brain activity, muscle paralysis, and vivid dreams. While the purpose of REM sleep is not yet fully understood, it is thought to be important for brain development, memory consolidation, and emotional processing.

REM sleep deprivation studies are often carried out on animals, with the most widely used method being the 'inverted flowerpot technique'. This involves placing an animal on a small platform surrounded by water, allowing it to fall asleep but causing it to fall into the water and wake up when it enters REM sleep and loses muscle tone.

REM sleep deprivation has been linked to various physical and mental health issues, including increased pain sensitivity, cognitive impairment, and mood disorders. However, it is not yet clear whether these effects are specifically due to REM sleep deprivation or general sleep disruption. More research is needed to fully understand the effects of REM sleep deprivation and the importance of REM sleep.

In a controlled laboratory setting with an EEG machine

REM sleep deprivation studies in a controlled laboratory setting with an EEG machine can be conducted by following these steps:

Participant Preparation:

Firstly, ensure that the participant has provided informed consent and is dressed in sleeping attire. It is also important to ensure that the participant's hair is clean and dry, as this will help the electrodes stick to their scalp more easily. Ask the participant to avoid using hair products such as gel or wax.

Electrode Application:

In a well-ventilated room, prepare the participant's scalp by clipping or pinning their hair back to expose the skin. Clean the area with isopropyl alcohol and use an abrading cream to remove dead skin and oils that may interfere with the EEG signals. Wipe off the cream and apply electrode conductive paste or gel to the scalp.

Place the EEG electrodes on the prepared sites, filling the cups with electrode paste or gel to ensure good electrical contact with the skin. The number and placement of electrodes will depend on the specific study requirements, but a standard configuration is the 10-20 electrode system. Secure the electrodes with collodion-soaked gauze, ensuring that the corners are glued down firmly.

For a sleep study, additional electrodes may be needed to monitor eye movements (electrooculogram, or EOG) and chin muscle activity (electromyogram, or EMG). Place these electrodes following standard procedures.

EEG Recorder Setup:

Connect the electrodes to the EEG recorder, ensuring proper grounding and impedance levels. Calibrate the recorder with an external signal of known amplitude, typically around 200-250 µV. Follow the manufacturer's instructions for any internal calibration procedures as well.

Sleep Deprivation Procedure:

Instruct the participant to lie down and relax. For a REM sleep deprivation study, the participant will need to be awakened whenever they enter REM sleep. This can be done by monitoring their brain activity and looking for the characteristic brain wave patterns of REM sleep. Alternatively, some studies use the "platform method," where the participant sleeps on a small platform surrounded by water, and the loss of muscle tone during REM sleep causes them to fall into the water, triggering an arousal. However, this method is stressful for the participant and is not recommended.

Data Analysis:

After the sleep deprivation procedure, remove the electrodes and clean the participant's scalp. Download the EEG data and analyse it using specialised software. Look for changes in brain activity, particularly in the gamma and theta frequency range during REM sleep. Compare the results with a control group or baseline measurements to identify any significant differences or trends.

Ethical Considerations:

It is important to note that sleep deprivation studies carry potential risks, including increased anxiety, irritability, and attention deficits. Ensure that the study adheres to all local and national regulations for the protection of human subjects. Provide participants with appropriate aftercare and monitor them for any side effects or adverse reactions.

By a doctor with an EEG machine in a controlled laboratory setting

REM sleep is the fourth stage of the sleep cycle, during which the eyes move rapidly, the heart rate increases, breathing becomes irregular, and brain activity is heightened. REM sleep is important for memory consolidation, emotional processing, brain development, and dreaming.

REM sleep deprivation studies can be conducted by a doctor with an EEG machine in a controlled laboratory setting. Here is a step-by-step guide on how this might be done:

Patient Preparation:

The patient is instructed to restrict their sleep, either by staying awake all night or sleeping for a limited number of hours, to induce a state of sleep deprivation. This step is crucial to ensure the patient's brain will enter the REM sleep phase during the experiment.

Electrode Placement:

Upon arrival at the laboratory, the patient's head is measured, and spots for electrode placement are marked. The technician then gently scrubs these areas with a gritty cream to ensure proper adhesion. Up to 27 small disc electrodes are pasted onto the patient's scalp, with additional electrodes placed on the shoulders to record heart rate and muscle activity.

Recording Setup:

The electrodes are connected to a 'headbox' and then to a recording machine. The patient is asked to relax, close their eyes, and take a few deep breaths. The technician monitors the patient's brain waves on a screen, waiting for the onset of REM sleep.

Sleep Monitoring:

Once the patient enters the REM sleep phase, the technician records their brain activity for 20 to 30 minutes. The patient's heart rate, muscle activity, and other relevant physiological data are also monitored during this time. It is important to ensure the patient's comfort and safety throughout the experiment.

Data Analysis:

After the recording session, the electrodes are carefully removed, and the patient's hair and scalp are cleaned. The data collected during the experiment is then analyzed by a neurologist or a specialist in sleep medicine. This analysis may include examining brain wave patterns, identifying any abnormal electrical activity, and comparing the results to those of previous studies.

Patient Follow-up:

The patient is likely to experience fatigue and drowsiness after the procedure, so it is recommended that they arrange for transportation back home. The results of the study are typically communicated to the patient during a follow-up appointment, where further steps or treatments may be discussed if necessary.

It is important to note that the specific procedures and protocols may vary depending on the healthcare provider and the specific research objectives. The comfort and safety of the patient should always be a top priority during these types of studies.

Using the hand arousal technique

The hand arousal technique is one of the methods used to conduct REM sleep deprivation studies. This method was first used by Dement, where a subject is awakened as and when one goes into sleep, NREMS or REMS, usually NREMS. To use this technique, one needs to record electrophysiological parameters defining sleep and waking. Based on such electrophysiological criteria, if a subject is awakened at the onset of every NREMS, the subject is almost certainly deprived of total sleep (NREMS as well as REMS) as REMS does not appear unless there is some amount of NREMS. On the other hand, if the subject is awakened only at the onset of every REMS, although apparently one may be deprived mostly of REMS, practically it is difficult to continue for longer durations. This is because, with increased duration of deprivation, REMS pressure builds up. This causes increased frequency of appearance of REMS, leading to frequent awakening and depriving the subjects of total sleep.

To rule out nonspecific effects, another control subject/animal (yoked control) is awakened an equal number of times (as that of the experimental subject) irrespective of the former's sleep state. It was observed that the experimental subject may be selectively deprived of total sleep or REMS to a reasonable extent only if the studies are continued for a short-term deprivation (limited) period. The method is not suitable to achieve long-term (for more than several hours to a couple of days) deprivation, particularly for REMSD. This is because, as the deprivation progresses, the NREMS and REMS pressure increases so much that the subject must be awakened frequently; also, the yoked control gets deprived of sleep. Besides, the method needs continuous monitoring, and therefore, if continued for longer, the experimenter is also deprived of sleep (unless several researchers take turns, which in turn may add variability though). Use of modern computer-aided techniques has limited human intervention; however, elaborate instrumentation and possible confounds due to instrumental use need careful planning. In this method, particularly for animal studies, electrodes need to be surgically implanted for recording the electrophysiological signals to objectively define and identify sleep and waking states.

With the treadmill arousal method

The treadmill arousal method is a technique used to deprive subjects of REM sleep. In this method, the subjects are placed on a treadmill, where the continuous movement of the belt prevents them from falling asleep. Ideally, this method deprives the subjects of both REM and non-REM sleep, keeping them awake throughout.

However, in practice, subjects often learn to run in the opposite direction of the belt's movement, allowing them to rest until they reach the end of the treadmill. As a result, they may experience some sleep, with reports indicating that subjects could enjoy up to 40% of their time on the treadmill in non-REM sleep. This technique was designed to avoid the movement restriction and associated stress experienced by subjects in other deprivation methods.

One modification of this method involves regulating the speed of the treadmill belt based on changes in the subject's EEG, so that when the subject enters REM sleep, the belt starts rolling, and the subject is awakened. This modification aims for more selective REM sleep deprivation but requires more elaborate arrangements or surgical implantation of electrodes.

By using the flowerpot method

The flowerpot method is an animal testing technique used in sleep deprivation studies. It is designed to allow NREM sleep but prevent restful REM sleep. The test is usually performed with rodents, typically rats.

In the flowerpot method, a rat is housed in a water-filled enclosure with a single small, dry platform (traditionally, an upside-down flower pot in a bucket of water) just above the water line. While in NREM sleep, the rat retains muscle tone and can sleep on top of the platform. When the rat enters REM sleep, it loses muscle tone and falls off the platform into the water, then climbs back up to avoid drowning, and re-enters NREM sleep. Alternatively, its nose may become submerged, shocking it back into an awakened state.

This method allows the rat to physically rest to avoid fatigue, but deprives it of REM sleep needed for normal mental function. The rat can then be subjected to physical and mental tasks, and its performance can be compared with the performance of rested control rodents.

The flowerpot method has been used in studies to investigate the effects of REM sleep deprivation on spatial memory in rats. These studies have found that REM sleep deprivation caused a significant impairment in reference spatial memory, as well as weight loss and increased serum corticosterone.

It is important to note that the flowerpot method may cause physical stress and loss of some NREM sleep in addition to REM sleep deprivation. Therefore, the results of studies using this method may not be solely due to REM sleep deprivation.

Frequently asked questions