Fitness Trackers: Unlocking Sleep Pattern Secrets

Sleep tracking is a common feature of fitness trackers, with many devices offering insights into sleep patterns and quality. While they don't directly measure sleep, they often estimate sleep by tracking inactivity and movement. This method, known as actigraphy, uses accelerometers and gyroscopes to monitor rest and activity. However, actigraphy has limitations and may not accurately distinguish between sleep stages. For precise sleep data, medical sleep studies that monitor brain waves are more reliable. Nonetheless, fitness trackers can provide valuable information on sleep habits, helping users recognise patterns and make adjustments for better rest.

Accelerometers and gyroscopes

The data collected by accelerometers is processed using heuristic algorithms to estimate sleep parameters such as sleep onset, interruptions, and duration. These algorithms can detect the sleep period time window (SPT-window), which starts at sleep onset and ends when the wearer wakes up. The accuracy of these algorithms has been evaluated in studies, with F1 scores ranging from 73.93% to over 93.31%.

While accelerometers provide valuable insights into sleep patterns, they have limitations. Accelerometers primarily track movement and cannot directly measure sleep. They may struggle to accurately track sleep in individuals with disrupted sleep or sleep disorders. The more disrupted the sleep, the less accurate the tracking tends to be. This is because sleep stages are primarily defined by brain activity, which accelerometers do not measure directly.

Gyroscopes are another type of motion sensor found in some fitness trackers, such as the Apple Watch. Gyroscopes measure the orientation of the device and can separate the force of gravity from the raw accelerometer measurements. This allows for more precise motion detection and helps improve the accuracy of sleep tracking.

In summary, accelerometers and gyroscopes in fitness trackers monitor movement and orientation to estimate sleep patterns. While they provide valuable insights, they have limitations and should be used in conjunction with other methods for more comprehensive sleep analysis.

Actigraphy and photoplethysmography (PPG)

Actigraphy is a method used in sleep studies that involves wearing a device, usually on the wrist, that tracks movement during sleep. The data collected by these devices is then translated into periods of sleep and wakefulness. Actigraphy is often used in sleep studies as it is a convenient way for people with sleep disorders or disrupted sleep to have their sleep patterns studied without having to sleep in a lab. However, actigraphy only tracks movement and does not account for brain waves and eye movements, which are important for accurately assessing sleep phases. As a result, actigraphy is generally more accurate for people with "normal" sleep patterns and less accurate for those with disrupted sleep or sleep disorders.

Photoplethysmography (PPG) is a non-invasive optical technique used in sleep tracking devices that measures physiologic parameters by producing a waveform that correlates with the circulatory volume in skin tissue. PPG is often combined with actigraphy to provide sleep data outputs that are familiar to clinicians, such as sleep times, restlessness, and movement. PPG has been shown to have higher sensitivity and accuracy in sleep/wake detection compared to actigraphy alone. Recent advancements in PPG signal acquisition and processing have also enabled its combination with accelerometry to construct hypnograms and detect sleep-disordered breathing. However, it is important to note that the efficacy of PPG-based sleep tracking devices can vary, and PPG-estimated sleep stages are currently not standardized across devices.

Accuracy and limitations

The accuracy of fitness trackers in monitoring sleep patterns has been the subject of multiple studies, with varying results. While the consensus is that they are generally accurate for healthy adults with "normal" sleep patterns, their accuracy decreases with the presence of sleep disorders or frequent sleep disruptions. This is because these devices primarily rely on tracking movement, while sleep stages are defined by brain activity.

Actigraphy, which is often used in sleep studies, is a method that uses a wrist-worn device to track movement during sleep. Software then translates these movements into periods of sleep and wakefulness. Actigraphy is considered generally accurate for healthy adults but struggles with distinguishing sleep stages. Polysomnography (PSG), which monitors brain waves to analyse sleep stages, is considered the gold standard for measuring sleep but is cumbersome and expensive.

Commercially available sleep trackers, such as the Fitbit Inspire 3, Oura Ring, and Whoop 4.0, offer a convenient and low-cost way to gather personalised sleep data. These devices can track sleep duration, sleep quality, and sleep phases, as well as additional health metrics such as heart rate, blood oxygen levels, body temperature, and respiratory rate. They can also provide insights, recommendations, and scores based on the data collected.

However, it is important to note that no commercially available sleep tracker can perfectly analyse sleep or diagnose sleep disorders. Their main limitation is the inability to directly measure sleep, instead relying on estimating sleep through inactivity or movement tracking. Additionally, the accuracy of these devices can vary depending on their position and the software used to analyse movement data. While they can identify trends in sleep patterns and provide valuable insights, they should not be solely relied upon for sleep disorder diagnosis.

Sleep stages and tracking

Sleep tracking devices can be useful in helping you recognise patterns in your sleep habits. They can collect a lot of information about your sleep habits and help you understand how much sleep you're getting. However, it's important to note that they don't measure sleep directly but often use inactivity as a surrogate for estimating sleep.

Sleep trackers can be worn on the wrist, clipped to a pillow, or placed on a bedside table. They can also be in the form of a smart ring, a headband, or even a smart mattress. These trackers use accelerometers to track your movements, including the speed and direction of your motion. This is how they differentiate between your activity during the day and when you're asleep.

Some trackers also prompt you to enter information about activities that can affect your sleep, such as caffeine intake, meal times, and stress levels. This additional data helps provide a more comprehensive understanding of your sleep patterns.

While these devices can provide valuable insights, they may not accurately distinguish between sleep stages. Sleep stages are primarily defined by brain activity, but most trackers rely on movement detection. As a result, they may struggle to differentiate between periods of inactivity and actual sleep.

For precise data on sleep stages, a medical sleep study is necessary. These studies monitor brain waves and eye movements to accurately analyse the different stages of sleep. However, sleep trackers can still be a convenient way to gain insights into your sleep habits and make adjustments for improved sleep quality.

Sleep tracking devices

There are a variety of sleep tracking devices on the market, with more being released all the time. Many are wearable trackers that you can strap to your wrist. Others clip to your pillow or sit on your bedside table. Some are designed to be worn on the body, such as on the wrist or finger, while others don't need to be worn on the body, like smart mattresses.

Wearable sleep trackers include the Apple Watch, Google Pixel Watch 2, Fitbit, Jawbone UP, WHOOP 4.0, and Oura Ring 4. These devices usually have built-in accelerometers and gyroscopes, which allow them to track and monitor your movement. They can also have other features, like a smart alarm or health and fitness tracking.

The Apple Watch Series 9 and 10 can track sleep cycles and sleep apnea, blood oxygen, body temperature, EKG, and irregular heart rate alerts. The Google Pixel Watch 2 has improved heart rate sensors and can track sleep stages, blood oxygen, skin temperature, and more. Fitbit uses accelerometers to track your movements and can detect sleep duration and quality. The WHOOP 4.0 is designed to be worn as a wristband and gathers detailed data about your sleep, including heart rate, respiratory rate, blood oxygen levels, and skin temperature. The Oura Ring 4 is a lightweight, stylish ring that measures your heart rate, temperature, and blood oxygen levels, providing three scores: Sleep Score, Activity Score, and Readiness Score.

Non-wearable sleep trackers include smart mattresses, which have sensors in the cover that can track sleep, and smartphone apps, which can provide meaningful data or integrate information from other sources. The Withings Sleep device is another example of a non-wearable tracker that gathers data on your heart rate, movement, breathing, and snoring.

Frequently asked questions