Fitbit Surge Sleep Tracking: How Accurate Is It?

Fitbit's sleep-tracking feature has been a topic of interest for many users. The device uses movement and heart-rate patterns to estimate sleep stages, with an accelerometer and optical photoplethysmography measuring bodily accelerations of the wrist and blood flow. While the accuracy of sleep staging has been questioned, Fitbit claims 69% accuracy in 30-second time windows. The device can help users understand their sleep patterns and make adjustments, but it is not intended for medical diagnosis or treatment. Users should consult a healthcare professional for any sleep-related concerns.

How does the Fitbit detect sleep?

Fitbit devices automatically detect sleep when they recognise that your body is going into sleep mode. This happens when you haven't moved for about an hour. The device records sleep of an hour or more, and when you sync your device in the morning, it uses your movement and heart rate patterns to estimate your sleep cycles from the previous night.

Fitbit devices that track heart rate can also track sleep stages. They do this by tracking the beat-to-beat changes in your heart rate, known as heart rate variability (HRV), which fluctuate as you transition between light sleep, deep sleep, and REM sleep stages.

Fitbit's sleep researchers and the National Sleep Foundation describe the following sleep stages:

• Light sleep: This is your entry point into sleep each night as your body unwinds and slows down.
• Deep sleep: A period of sleep with less brain activity than REM sleep.
• REM sleep: The stage associated with vivid dreams, where brain activity is more similar to when we are awake.

The accuracy of sleep tracking varies depending on the model of Fitbit. Some users have reported that their Fitbit accurately detected their sleep, while others have found that their device underestimated their sleep duration.

In addition to sleep tracking, Fitbit devices with a microphone can also track noise and snoring. This feature allows the device to track the overall noise level of your surroundings and check for snoring throughout the night. It's important to note that this feature is not intended to diagnose or treat any medical conditions and should not be relied upon for medical purposes.

How accurate is the Fitbit Surge's sleep tracking?

The accuracy of the Fitbit Surge's sleep tracking has been questioned by some users, who have reported discrepancies between the data provided by the device and their actual sleep patterns. For example, a user on Reddit shared that the Fitbit Surge reported a later bedtime than the actual time they fell asleep. This user also expressed uncertainty about whether the data indicated a genuine problem with falling asleep.

It is important to note that the Fitbit Surge, unlike other Fitbit devices, does not track heart rate. Instead, it relies solely on movement to detect sleep. According to Fitbit, when a user hasn't moved in about an hour, the device assumes they are asleep. This movement data is then used to estimate sleep cycles and provide a breakdown of sleep stages, including light sleep, deep sleep, and REM sleep. However, it is worth mentioning that the sleep sensitivity setting on the device does not affect the sleep stages reported.

While the Surge's sleep tracking may not capture the exact sleep and wake times, it can still provide valuable insights into overall sleep patterns and help users understand their sleep habits. Fitbit's sleep tracking technology has evolved, and newer models incorporate heart rate tracking and other data to estimate sleep stages more accurately. These newer models offer a more comprehensive analysis of sleep patterns, allowing users to track their sleep cycles, sleep duration, and sleep quality.

According to a paper published by Fitbit scientists in 2017, the watch's sensors can classify sleep stages with 69% accuracy in any given 30-second time window. While this accuracy may seem low, it is important to consider the context. The accuracy rate indicates that the Fitbit's sleep staging is correct slightly more than two-thirds of the time. Therefore, users should interpret the sleep staging data with some degree of flexibility, especially when using the device for only one night.

In conclusion, while the Fitbit Surge's sleep tracking may not be perfectly accurate, it can still provide users with valuable feedback on their sleep patterns. Newer Fitbit models have improved accuracy by incorporating heart rate tracking and other advanced features, offering a more detailed analysis of sleep stages and overall sleep quality.

How does the Fitbit Surge compare to newer models?

The Fitbit Surge is a sophisticated piece of machinery in the form of a touchscreen wristwatch. It is a heart-rate monitor and activity tracker with a wide range of features for the serious sports and fitness enthusiast. It has a larger, swipeable display that shows real-time fitness stats and is lightweight despite its bulk. It has eight sensors, including a 3-axis accelerometer, gyroscope, compass, ambient light sensor, GPS, and heart rate monitor. It can record multi-sport activities such as running, cross-training, hiking, and cardio/strength workouts, and it can also track sleep. It is perfect for someone who wants to wear it daily and occasionally use its GPS tracking for dedicated training sessions.

The Fitbit Surge has been upgraded over the years, with significant improvements to auto-detect for walking, running, biking, elliptical training, and generalized workouts. The heart rate monitor has been improved with Pure Pulse, and the GPS is now much better. The newer versions of the Fitbit Surge also have faster data transfer and better damage resistance.

Compared to other Fitbit models, the Surge is an upgrade from the Charge and Flex, with more features and a nicer design. It is also more expensive than these models, costing £199.99/ $249.95. The Fitbit Charge 2 and Blaze are similar to the Surge in terms of features, but the Surge has built-in GPS, which the Charge 2 and Blaze lack. The Fitbit Flex 2 and Charge 2 are aimed at more casual users, while the Surge is for more committed sports and fitness enthusiasts.

When compared to other trackers on the market, the Fitbit Surge is one of the best options for day-to-day activity tracking with only occasional dedicated training. However, it is not as sleek-looking as some may want, and it is quite chunky. It also has a below-average battery life when the GPS is enabled, and the charger is not interchangeable with other Fitbits. The Fitbit Surge was phased out of Fitbit's lineup in 2018, with newer models likely to have further improvements.

How does the Fitbit Surge's sleep tracking affect sleep scores?

Fitbit's sleep tracking uses an accelerometer to measure bodily accelerations of the wrist, coupled with a technique called optical photoplethysmography or PPG. PPG measures blood flow based on how green light from an LED on the back of the watch is reflected by the body. It also uses movement and heart-rate patterns to estimate sleep cycles. When you don't move for about an hour, your Fitbit assumes you're asleep, and additional data such as the length of time when your movements indicate sleep behaviour (like rolling over) help confirm your sleep status.

Fitbit's sleep tracking can help improve your sleep score by providing insights into your sleep data, including your sleeping heart rate. Your sleep score is based on your heart rate, the time you spend awake or restless, and your sleep stages. The sleep score can help you understand your sleep patterns and make adjustments to improve your sleep quality.

While the Fitbit Surge model does not track heart rate, it can still provide information about your sleep patterns by detecting your movement during sleep. If the device detects excessive movement, it will record that time as awake, as restful sleep would not be possible with significant motion.

It's important to note that the sleep sensitivity setting on your device does not affect the sleep stages recorded. To accurately track your sleep, ensure your Fitbit is positioned higher on your wrist, about 2-3 finger widths above the wrist bone, with the band secure but not too tight. Additionally, you can edit your sleep log in the Fitbit app, and your sleep score will adjust accordingly.

The accuracy of Fitbit's sleep tracking has been questioned, with a 2017 paper by Fitbit scientists reporting a 69% accuracy in any given 30-second time window. This means that Fitbit's sleep staging is only correct slightly more than two-thirds of the time, and this information is not explicitly communicated to users in the app. Therefore, it is recommended to consider the context and not rely solely on a single night of sleep tracking data.

How does the Fitbit Surge's sleep tracking compare to other methods?

The Fitbit Surge is an older model of Fitbit device that does not track heart rate. It detects that you are asleep when you haven't moved in about an hour. It also records the time spent awake, restless, and asleep.

Newer Fitbit devices with heart-rate tracking can find a record of the sleep stages the user cycles through, including light sleep, deep sleep, and REM sleep. They do this by tracking the beat-to-beat changes in the user's heart rate, known as heart rate variability (HRV), which fluctuate as the user transitions between sleep stages. These devices can also track noise, including snoring, when the user is asleep.

Compared to the Fitbit Surge, newer Fitbit devices with heart-rate tracking provide a more detailed analysis of the user's sleep. They can estimate the sleep stages the user cycles through, whereas the Fitbit Surge can only provide a breakdown of the time spent awake, restless, and asleep. Additionally, the newer devices can track noise and snoring, which the Fitbit Surge cannot do.

However, it is worth noting that even the newer Fitbit devices with heart-rate tracking may not provide a completely accurate representation of the user's sleep. For example, a user may assume they are experiencing sleep issues based on the data provided by their Fitbit, when in reality, the data may not be entirely accurate. Additionally, the sleep sensitivity setting on the device does not affect sleep stages, so users cannot adjust the setting to get a more accurate reading.

Frequently asked questions