Smartwatch Sleep Tracking: How Reliable Is It?

Smartwatches have become increasingly popular for sleep tracking, with one in three Americans having used a sleep-tracking device. While they are a practical, cost-effective tool for monitoring sleep habits, questions have been raised about the accuracy of these devices. Most sleep trackers work by monitoring body movements and heart rate changes to determine sleep versus wakefulness and the different sleep stages. However, studies show that sleep trackers may struggle to differentiate between sleep and wakefulness, especially in people with insomnia who tend to remain very still. Additionally, the algorithms used by companies to make predictions about sleep are often unknown, making it challenging to validate the accuracy of the data. Nevertheless, some devices, like the Oura Ring, Google Pixel Watch, and Apple Watch, have been found to offer a good combination of accuracy and user experience.

Accuracy of smart rings

Smart rings, such as the Oura Ring, are another type of wearable sleep tracker. They are more basic than smartwatches and use sensors along the inside of the ring to collect data and track your sleep. The Oura Ring Gen3 and the Oura Ring 4 have been found to be the most accurate sleep trackers in terms of measuring heart rate and heart-rate variability. They also offer the most comprehensive and approachable data and daily guidance. The Oura Ring 4 has smart sensors that allow more accurate and continuous data capture.

However, the Oura Ring may not be the best choice for active individuals who want to measure workouts and movement as comprehensively as sleep tracking. The Whoop 4.0 is a good alternative in this case, as it accurately tracks both sleep and daily activity.

While the convenience, low cost, and easy accessibility of consumer sleep trackers have contributed to their enormous popularity, there are limitations to the data they collect. Research shows that they are good at detecting periods of sleep but less effective at determining wake periods, which means they may overestimate the overall time a wearer spends asleep each night. This is because they primarily measure movement and only some of them track heart rate changes during sleep. Watches that incorporate heart rate data tend to be slightly more accurate when measuring sleep duration because heart rate fluctuates during different sleep stages. However, experts are still uncertain about their accuracy due to the limited research on them and the differences between each device.

Furthermore, the algorithms used by companies to make predictions about sleep are unknown, making it difficult to identify whether the assumptions made by the trackers are valid. For instance, sleep devices tend to underperform in people with insomnia as they remain very still in bed in an attempt to fall asleep, and watches are unable to differentiate sleep from wakefulness in such cases.

It is also important to note that the data from these sleep trackers could change your emotional state and concentration levels during the day, even if the readings are accurate. This was demonstrated by a study where participants were given sleep watches and their "sleep score" was manipulated to show either an increased or a decreased quality of sleep. The study found that those who were told they had a poor night's sleep showed lower mood, difficulties with daytime thinking processes, and increased sleepiness.

Accuracy of smartwatches

The accuracy of smartwatches as sleep trackers varies across different devices and brands. While some sources claim that the Apple Watch Series 8 is inaccurate in measuring sleep time, others claim that the Apple Watch 8 is better than other devices at measuring sleep efficiency and sleep latency. The Oura Ring Gen3 and 4 have also been praised for their accuracy in tracking sleep cycles, total sleep time, and heart rate variability. The Google Pixel Watch 2 has also been deemed one of the most accurate Fitbit-powered wearables for heart rate and GPS tracking.

Smartwatches, like other sleep trackers, have their limitations and may not be 100% accurate. They work by monitoring body movements and, in some cases, heart rate changes to determine sleep versus wakefulness. This means that they may struggle to differentiate sleep from wakefulness in people who are very still while trying to fall asleep, such as those with insomnia. Watches that incorporate heart rate data tend to be more accurate in measuring sleep duration because heart rate fluctuates during different sleep stages. However, experts are still uncertain about the accuracy of these devices due to limited research and differences between each device.

Some studies have found that certain smartwatches perform well in measuring sleep stages. For example, the Google Pixel Watch, Galaxy Watch 5, and Amazon Halo Rise were found to have high macro F1 scores for the REM stage, indicating relatively higher agreement with polysomnography results. The Fitbit Sense 2, Galaxy Watch 5, and Google Pixel Watch also demonstrated high levels of performance for the light sleep stage.

It is worth noting that the accuracy of smartwatches and other sleep trackers can have a significant impact on users. A study found that participants who were told they had a poor night's sleep based on their watch's "sleep score" experienced a lower mood, difficulties with thinking processes, and increased sleepiness during the day. This suggests that the data from sleep trackers can influence a person's emotional state and concentration levels, even if the readings may not be entirely accurate.

While smartwatches and other sleep trackers can provide insights into sleep patterns, it is important for users to interpret the data with a degree of skepticism and not solely rely on these devices for assessing sleep quality. The best metric for measuring sleep quality is often how one feels each day, and simple adjustments, such as going to bed earlier, can help improve sleep without the need for a device.

Accuracy of under-mattress trackers

Under-mattress sleep trackers are non-wearable devices that are designed to fit between your mattress and the base of your bed. They are usually shaped like small mats, such as the Withings Sleep Tracker Pad, and are packed with advanced sensors that can track your sleep patterns, including your breathing, movements, and heart rate. The data collected is then sent to a corresponding app, which provides insights into your sleep quality and duration, as well as sleep trends over time.

One of the main drawbacks of under-mattress sleep trackers is their accuracy. The presence of a mattress between the user and the device may impact the precision of the results, particularly for health metrics like heart rate and body temperature, as the sensors are not in direct contact with the user's skin. Additionally, thick and dense mattresses may further reduce the sensitivity of the sensors, leading to less accurate data. However, some under-mattress trackers are designed to compensate for thick mattresses.

Despite the accuracy concerns, under-mattress sleep trackers offer a non-invasive and unobtrusive solution for those who find wearable devices uncomfortable or bothersome. They provide valuable information about sleep patterns and can help individuals who are curious about their sleep quality or have irregular work schedules. It is recommended to research and choose an under-mattress tracker that has been tested for accuracy and has positive reviews to ensure the best results.

Impact of sleep trackers on mental health

Sleep is essential for maintaining good mental and physical health. It helps repair and restore our brains and bodies, and is crucial for processing information, consolidating memories, and undergoing maintenance processes that help us function during the day. Poor sleep can increase the risk of poor health, and vice versa, creating a cycle that is challenging to break. Common mental health issues like anxiety and depression often contribute to sleep problems, and addressing these issues in tandem is often the most effective approach.

Sleep trackers have become increasingly popular as people become more concerned about getting enough sleep. These devices can provide insights into sleep patterns and help users establish better sleep routines. However, it's important to recognize that sleep trackers don't directly measure sleep. Instead, they estimate sleep by monitoring body movements and, in some cases, heart rate changes. While they can be useful tools, it's important to take their data with a grain of salt and maintain a healthy perspective on sleep.

The impact of sleep trackers on mental health is a complex issue. On the one hand, sleep trackers can help raise awareness about the importance of sleep and encourage users to prioritize their sleep health. They can also provide insights that help users understand their sleep patterns and make positive changes to their sleep habits. For individuals who are generally healthy and want to gain insight into their sleep patterns, sleep trackers can be a good option.

However, there are potential downsides to using sleep trackers. One concern is the accuracy of the data. Sleep trackers that rely solely on movement may struggle to differentiate between sleep and wakefulness, especially in individuals with insomnia who tend to remain very still while trying to fall asleep. Even trackers that incorporate heart rate data, which tend to be more accurate, have limitations due to the differences between devices and the lack of research validating their algorithms. As a result, it's challenging to determine their accuracy definitively.

Additionally, the data from sleep trackers can influence users' emotional states and concentration levels. A study found that participants who were told they had a poor night's sleep, based on their tracker's data, exhibited lower mood, difficulties with daytime thinking processes, and increased sleepiness, even when their actual sleep quality was the same as those who were told they had a good night's sleep. This demonstrates the potential for sleep trackers to negatively impact mental health and well-being, even when the data they provide may not be entirely accurate.

Furthermore, the use of sleep trackers has been linked to orthosomnia, a term coined by sleep specialists to describe the obsession with achieving perfect sleep data. While not considered a medical disorder, orthosomnia can lead to unhealthy fixation on sleep data, even when contradicted by medical professionals. This can contribute to sleep-related anxiety and further impact mental health.

In conclusion, while sleep trackers can offer insights into sleep patterns, their impact on mental health is nuanced. They may help raise awareness and encourage healthy sleep habits, but they also have the potential to cause anxiety, obsession, and negative emotional responses. It's important for users to maintain a balanced perspective on sleep and remember that sleep trackers are not a substitute for good sleep hygiene practices and seeking professional help for sleep disorders or persistent sleep problems.

How do sleep trackers work?

Sleep trackers are devices that monitor and analyse sleep patterns. They are usually in the form of smartwatches, rings, or under-mattress trackers. While they are a convenient way to track sleep, the accuracy of these devices varies.

Smartwatches are the most popular type of sleep tracker. They are worn on the wrist and use sensors to monitor body movements and, in some cases, heart rate changes, to determine the amount of time spent asleep and the different sleep stages. Examples of popular smartwatches include the Apple Watch Series 8 and 9, Google Pixel Watch 2 and 3, and the Garmin Venu 3S.

Rings, such as the Oura Ring Gen3 and 4, and the Samsung Galaxy Ring, are another type of wearable sleep tracker. They use sensors along the inside of the ring to collect data and track sleep. These rings are more basic than smartwatches but can still provide insights into sleep efficiency, restfulness, readiness, and heart rate variability.

Under-mattress trackers, like the Withings Sleep Tracker Pad and the Withings Sleep Analyzer, are unobtrusive solutions that slide under your mattress. However, they may assume that you are trying to sleep if you are lying still in bed, which can skew the results.

While sleep trackers can provide valuable insights into sleep patterns, it is important to note that their accuracy has been questioned. Some studies have shown that they are good at detecting sleep but less effective at determining wake periods, which can lead to an overestimation of total sleep time. Additionally, their algorithms are often unknown, making it difficult to validate their assumptions. Furthermore, sleep trackers have been found to underperform in people with insomnia, as they only measure movement and may not differentiate between sleep and wakefulness in individuals who remain very still while trying to fall asleep.

Despite these limitations, sleep trackers have become increasingly popular due to their convenience, low cost, and ability to provide personalised sleep data. They can be useful for individuals who want to establish better sleep routines, but it is recommended that those with poor sleep or mental health conditions use them with caution, as they may contribute to sleep-related anxiety.

Frequently asked questions