Tracking Sleep: A Double-Edged Sword For Sleep Quality

Sleep tracking is an increasingly popular way to monitor sleep patterns and quality. Sleep tracking devices can be worn on the body or placed in the bedroom, and they use various metrics such as heart rate, movement, and sound to estimate sleep duration and quality. While these devices can provide valuable insights into sleep habits and help people make positive changes, it is important to remember that they do not directly measure sleep and may not always provide accurate data. Additionally, obsessing over nightly sleep data can lead to sleep anxiety, which can ironically worsen sleep quality.

Sleep trackers can be inaccurate

Sleep trackers can collect a lot of information about sleep habits and can be useful for recognising patterns. They can detect interrupted sleep, for example, by tracking when a person is tossing and turning or waking during the night. They can also track the phases of sleep and time an alarm to go off during a period of lighter sleep. Some also record environmental factors such as light and temperature.

However, the classification of sleep stages remains unreliable and inconsistent. There is a risk that users become preoccupied with optimising their sleep data, a phenomenon known as orthosomnia. This can lead to unhelpful behaviours such as spending longer in bed, which can worsen sleep quality and quantity. Sleep trackers can even make insomnia worse if people spend more time in bed lying awake.

Sleep trackers are also not designed or approved to diagnose sleep disorders or other health problems. They should not be trusted over more objective testing, such as an overnight sleep study in a specialised clinic. It is important to take the data with a grain of salt and not to become overly anxious about sleep.

Sleep tracking can cause anxiety

Sleep tracking has become a common practice with the advent of wearable technology and smartphone apps. While these tools can provide insights into sleep patterns, they may also have unintended consequences, such as causing anxiety in users. This phenomenon, known as "orthosomnia" or "orthoinsomnia", is characterized by an obsession with achieving perfect sleep metrics as indicated by the tracking devices.

Orthosomnia is not a medical disorder but rather an anxiety phenomenon. It occurs when individuals become overly fixated on the data provided by sleep trackers, believing it to be highly accurate. This can lead to unhelpful behaviors, such as spending more time in bed to improve their sleep tracker data, which ironically worsens sleep quality and quantity. The condition was coined by combining "ortho", referring to straight or proper, and "somnia", meaning sleep.

The impact of sleep trackers on anxiety is twofold. Firstly, the data provided by sleep trackers may be inaccurate or unreliable, leading to a misunderstanding of one's sleep quality. This can cause anxiety and worry, especially if the app indicates that the user is not getting enough sleep or has inconsistent sleep patterns. Secondly, the very act of tracking sleep can induce stress and anxiety, as individuals become preoccupied with achieving perfect sleep metrics. This preoccupation can compromise sleep quality and even lead to the development of insomnia.

While sleep tracking can provide some benefits, such as raising awareness of the importance of sleep, it is important to approach these tools with caution. Users should be mindful of the potential for anxiety and orthosomnia, and seek professional guidance if they find themselves becoming overly fixated on sleep data. Maintaining a healthy perspective on sleep and prioritizing overall well-being are crucial to avoiding the negative impacts of sleep tracking.

Sleep tracking can improve awareness

Sleep tracking can help improve awareness about your sleep patterns and habits. Sleep tracking devices can provide insights into your sleep duration, quality, and disturbances. By tracking your sleep, you can identify patterns and behaviours that impact your sleep quality. For example, you can discover whether you sleep better when your bedroom is cooler or on days you exercise. This awareness can empower you to make positive changes and improve your sleep hygiene.

Sleep tracking devices use various methods to estimate sleep. They often measure inactivity and track movement, heart rate, and sound to determine sleep duration and quality. Some devices also prompt you to input lifestyle factors, such as caffeine intake, diet, and stress levels, which can provide additional context for understanding your sleep patterns. While these devices are becoming more accurate at detecting sleep and wake cycles, it's important to remember that they don't directly measure sleep quality.

The data provided by sleep trackers can help you reflect on your sleep habits and make informed decisions to improve your sleep. For example, if you notice that you're frequently disturbed during the night, you might decide to adjust your bedtime routine or create a more comfortable sleep environment. Tracking your sleep can also help identify potential sleep disorders or underlying health issues, encouraging proactive health decisions and consultations with healthcare professionals.

However, it's important to maintain a balanced perspective on the data provided by sleep trackers. While they can offer valuable insights, they might not always provide entirely accurate information. There is a risk of becoming preoccupied with optimising sleep data, leading to a condition known as orthosomnia, characterised by an obsession with achieving perfect sleep metrics. Therefore, it's crucial to avoid sleep anxiety and maintain a holistic approach to sleep, considering factors such as stress levels, diet, and exercise habits alongside the data provided by sleep trackers.

Sleep tracking can help with sleep disorders

Sleep tracking can be a useful tool for people who want to gain insight into their sleep patterns and habits. Sleep tracking devices can help users recognise patterns in their sleep habits and identify factors that may be interrupting their sleep. For example, a sleep tracker can help you determine if you feel more energetic after sleeping from 11 pm to 7 am instead of 10 pm to 6 am, or if your sleep is disrupted by caffeine consumption after lunchtime.

Sleep tracking devices can also help users establish and work towards goals for their sleep. Many sleep trackers have “sleep coach” functions that give users feedback based on the patterns detected. Users can also set smart alarms to wake them up when they are in the lightest phase of sleep.

While sleep tracking devices cannot be used to diagnose sleep disorders, they can help users identify potential symptoms and track their sleep data over time. This information can then be shared with a doctor or healthcare provider, who can interpret the data and determine if any interventions are necessary. Sleep tracking devices can be especially useful for people who suspect they are not getting enough sleep and want to identify factors that may be interrupting their rest.

However, it is important to note that sleep tracking devices have limitations and should not be solely relied upon for diagnosing sleep disorders. The data provided by these devices may not always be entirely accurate, and there is a risk of developing an unhealthy preoccupation with sleep tracking, known as orthosomnia. It is recommended to consult a healthcare practitioner if you have concerns about your sleep quality or if you are experiencing significant sleep issues such as sleep apnea or chronic insomnia.

Sleep tracking can help with lifestyle factors

Sleep tracking can be a great way to gain awareness about the importance of sleep and help you make positive changes to your lifestyle. While the technology is still improving, and the data should be taken with a pinch of salt, it can be a useful tool to reflect on your sleep patterns and make informed decisions about improving your sleep habits.

Sleep tracking devices can help you identify patterns and behaviours that impact the quality of your sleep. For example, you might discover that you sleep better when your bedroom is cooler, or on days when you exercise. You might also find that your sleep is disrupted if you have caffeine after lunchtime. This information can then help you adjust your habits and make positive changes to your lifestyle, leading to more restful and rejuvenating sleep.

Many sleep trackers allow you to input information about activities that can affect your sleep, such as caffeine intake, diet, and stress levels. This can help you to identify any lifestyle factors that may be impacting your sleep quality. For example, you might discover that your sleep is disturbed on days when you are particularly stressed, or when you have a higher caffeine intake. This information can then help you to make changes to your lifestyle, such as reducing your caffeine intake or finding ways to manage your stress, which can ultimately improve your sleep quality.

Additionally, sleep tracking can help you to identify any underlying health issues or potential sleep disorders. For example, if you consistently notice that you are not getting enough sleep or that your sleep is frequently disrupted, this could be a sign of a larger health issue. In this case, it is important to seek medical advice and make any necessary lifestyle changes to improve your sleep and overall health.

Overall, sleep tracking can be a valuable tool to help you understand the impact of lifestyle factors on your sleep quality. By reflecting on the data and making informed decisions, you can make positive changes to your lifestyle and improve your sleep habits, ultimately leading to improved health and well-being. However, it is important to maintain a balanced perspective on the data and not let it cause sleep anxiety or obsession, as this can ironically worsen your sleep quality.

Frequently asked questions