Home Sleep Study: Does It Track Rem Sleep?

Sleep is a complex process that involves various stages, including REM (rapid eye movement) sleep, which is characterised by vivid dreaming and is considered vital for good health. Measuring REM sleep typically involves tracking brainwaves through an electroencephalogram (EEG) to determine the duration and quality of sleep. While in-lab sleep studies are comprehensive and involve monitoring brain activity, advancements in technology have led to the emergence of at-home sleep tests. These tests offer a convenient and affordable option for individuals experiencing sleep issues, particularly those suspected of having sleep apnea. However, it is important to recognise that home sleep tests have limitations and may not be suitable for everyone, especially those with mild sleep apnea or other sleep disorders.

Home sleep studies can detect sleep apnea

Home sleep studies can be an effective way to detect sleep apnea. They are designed to help diagnose obstructive sleep apnea (OSA) at home. As you sleep, the device monitors your breathing and oxygen levels to detect and measure pauses in breathing, which are known as apneas.

Home sleep apnea tests are best suited for people who are suspected of having moderate to severe OSA that isn't complicated by other disorders. They are a more convenient, flexible, and affordable option than in-lab tests. They are also a good alternative for those who live far from a sleep clinic, have scheduling constraints, or simply prefer the comfort of their own bed.

The process for a home sleep apnea test typically involves attaching sensors to your body that are connected to a portable monitor. These sensors can include a small probe over your finger to measure oxygen levels, tubes inserted into your nostrils to measure airflow, and sensors placed on your abdomen and chest to measure their rise and fall as you breathe. The test usually only takes place over one night.

After the test, a sleep technologist will review your results and send them to your physician. If symptoms persist or the results are inconclusive, your doctor may recommend an in-lab sleep study, which can provide a more comprehensive assessment of sleep issues.

Home sleep apnea tests are generally effective in detecting sleep apnea, with a 98% accuracy rate in some cases. However, they have some limitations. They do not measure sleep quality or brain activity, so they cannot be used to diagnose other sleep disorders. Additionally, they may underestimate the severity of sleep apnea due to differences in how respiratory events are calculated.

They monitor breathing, not sleep

Home sleep tests are a convenient and affordable way to check for sleep disorders, specifically sleep-disordered breathing issues like sleep apnea. However, it is important to note that these tests monitor breathing and not actual sleep. While they can provide valuable insights into breathing patterns and sleep apnea severity, they do not capture the full range of data that an overnight sleep study in a lab can provide.

Home sleep tests are designed to evaluate a patient for sleep apnea by monitoring specific breathing parameters. They track breathing patterns, oxygen levels, and breathing effort. This includes measuring pauses and absence of breathing, the effort required to breathe, and whether breathing is deep or shallow. These tests help determine if a patient suffers from sleep apnea by providing data on respiratory events that cause a significant decrease in airflow.

While home sleep tests are useful for detecting sleep apnea, they do not analyse how much light or deep sleep an individual is getting. They are not meant to assess sleep quality or sleep architecture. Instead, they focus on breathing-related measures, such as airflow and breathing effort, and heart-related measures, such as heart rate. This information is crucial for diagnosing sleep apnea but does not provide a comprehensive view of sleep patterns and quality.

In contrast, overnight sleep studies conducted in a lab offer a more thorough assessment of sleep issues. These studies are attended by sleep technologists and capture a wider range of signals, including brainwaves, muscle tone, and leg movements. By monitoring brain activity, lab sleep studies can determine which stage of sleep an individual is in and observe any irregularities. They can detect not only sleep apnea but also other sleep disorders that do not affect the airways, such as movement disorders and narcolepsy.

Therefore, while home sleep tests are valuable tools for monitoring breathing and detecting sleep apnea, they do not measure actual sleep. They are limited in their ability to provide a complete picture of an individual's sleep quality and patterns. For a more comprehensive evaluation of sleep, an overnight sleep study in a lab is recommended.

An EEG headband can measure REM sleep at home

REM, or Rapid Eye Movement sleep, is the sleep phase where you dream most vividly. While the exact reason for the importance of dreaming to the brain is unclear, REM sleep is vital to good health. Adequate REM sleep has been linked to improved memory and stimulation of brain regions associated with learning.

Measuring REM Sleep

The only way to measure how much REM sleep you are getting is to monitor your brainwaves. This can be done with an electroencephalogram (EEG), which involves placing a headband on your forehead to pick up signals from your brain. This method is easy to use and can be done at home.

EEG Headbands

EEG headbands are a type of wearable technology that has emerged in recent years, offering a comfortable and patient-friendly way to monitor brain activity during sleep. These headbands are typically equipped with dry electrodes that sit on the forehead, ear, or neck, and can be worn for multiple nights, making them ideal for longitudinal data collection.

One example of an EEG headband is the Dreem Headband, which has been validated in a study for its ability to monitor sleep-related physiological signals and process them accurately into sleep stages. The headband showed an overall accuracy of 83.5% for automatic sleep staging, which is comparable to the average accuracy of 86.4% achieved by five sleep experts.

Benefits of Home Sleep Studies

Home sleep studies offer several advantages over traditional sleep centre studies. They are more cost-effective, provide comfort and convenience by allowing individuals to sleep in their own beds, and may yield more accurate readings as individuals are in their usual sleep environment.

In conclusion, EEG headbands are a viable option for measuring REM sleep at home. These devices offer a convenient and accurate way to monitor sleep, providing valuable insights into sleep architecture and enabling early detection of potential sleep disorders.

In-lab sleep studies are more comprehensive

In-lab sleep studies are far more comprehensive than home sleep studies. While home sleep studies are a good option for those who suspect they may have uncomplicated Obstructive Sleep Apnea (OSA), they are not suitable for those with underlying health conditions. In-lab sleep studies, on the other hand, can diagnose a much wider range of sleep disorders, including all three types of sleep apnea: Obstructive Sleep Apnea, Complex/Mixed Sleep Apnea, and Central Sleep Apnea, as well as REM sleep disorders, sleep-related seizures, and movement disorders such as restless leg syndrome, narcolepsy, and insomnia.

In-lab sleep studies involve placing sensors on the head, face, chest, and limbs to record a variety of data, including breathing, muscle and eye movements, brain wave changes, oxygen levels, blood pressure, and electrical activity of the heart (EKG). This allows doctors to accurately diagnose a range of sleep disorders and, in some cases, even begin treatment during the study. For example, if apnea is diagnosed during an in-lab study, continuous positive airway pressure (CPAP) can be started that night to find the right therapeutic pressure for the patient.

In contrast, home sleep studies typically only measure breathing and blood oxygen levels and do not measure brain activity with an electroencephalogram (EEG). This means that home studies cannot accurately determine the amount of time the patient is awake or asleep during the test. While some home studies are now starting to use EEG, in-lab studies remain the gold standard for comprehensive sleep evaluation and diagnosis.

The accuracy of home sleep studies is also limited by the fact that sensors may fall off during the night, whereas in-lab studies have a physician on-site to monitor the patient and ensure the integrity of the data. In-lab studies are also better equipped to handle patients with certain heart, breathing, or neuromuscular problems that may affect the results of a home sleep study.

While in-lab sleep studies are more invasive and expensive than home sleep studies, they offer a much more comprehensive evaluation of sleep health and are essential for diagnosing a wide range of sleep disorders beyond OSA.

Home sleep studies are cheaper and less invasive

Home sleep studies are a convenient and cost-effective way to check for sleep disorders, such as sleep apnea, from the comfort of your own home. They are more affordable than in-lab sleep studies, often between $150 to $500, and may be covered by insurance. The equipment is delivered to your doorstep, and you can perform the test in your own bed. This means you can stick to your normal sleep schedule and won't have to travel to a sleep lab, making the process less invasive and more appealing to those who may not be able to get to a clinic.

Home sleep studies are simplified breathing monitors that track your breathing, oxygen levels, and breathing effort. They do not measure brain activity or sleep architecture like in-lab studies, so they cannot fully capture the same data as an overnight sleep study. However, they are still useful for detecting sleep apnea, as this condition is characterised by breathing interruptions during sleep. Home sleep studies can also measure other factors like heart rate, snoring frequency, volume, and body movement.

The process for a home sleep study typically involves meeting with a medical professional, getting the equipment, performing the test, returning the equipment, and then meeting again to discuss the results. A prescription from your doctor is required to obtain a home sleep test. The equipment may include nasal breathing sensors, an effort belt, a pulse oximeter, a microphone, and a data collection device. The sensors are placed on your finger, nostrils, abdomen, and chest to measure various parameters.

While home sleep studies are a great option for those with suspected moderate to severe sleep apnea and no other health conditions, they may not be suitable for everyone. For individuals with mild sleep apnea or other sleep disorders, an in-lab sleep study may be necessary. In-lab studies can diagnose a wider range of sleep disorders, including narcolepsy and periodic limb movement disorders, as they measure brain activity and can provide a more comprehensive analysis of sleep issues.

Frequently asked questions