Wristband Sleep Tracking: Accurate Or Not?

Sleep trackers are devices that collect information about your sleep habits. They can be in the form of wristbands, smartwatches, rings, or even under-mattress sensors. While they don't directly measure sleep, they use various metrics such as heart rate, movement, and breathing to estimate sleep patterns and cycles. Some popular options include the Fitbit Inspire 3, Oura Ring, Whoop 4.0, and smartwatches from Apple, Samsung, and Garmin. These devices can provide insights into your sleep habits and help you develop better sleep routines.

Wrist sleep trackers monitor sleep through inactivity estimation

Sleep trackers are all the rage, and many people use devices on their wrists to monitor their sleep. These devices can monitor everything from heart rate and oxygen consumption to the number of steps taken each day. They can also track sleep duration and quality. While they don't directly measure sleep, they often estimate sleep by measuring inactivity. This means that they record when you fall asleep by tracking the time you're inactive and when you wake up by tracking when you start moving again.

Wearables for your wrist are a popular category of sleep trackers. These include rings, wristbands, and advanced smartwatches. They tend to be lightweight, and many can collect health data throughout the day, not just during sleep. For example, the Apple Watch Series 10 offers sleep cycles and sleep apnea tracking in addition to Wi-Fi, Bluetooth, GPS, and cellular options. However, it has been noted that even the lightest smartwatch pales in comparison to a smart ring for sleep-tracking functionality.

The WHOOP tracker is another example of a sleep tracker that can be worn as a wristband. It gathers detailed data about your sleep and works as a high-level fitness tracker. It helps optimize sleep by monitoring your heart rate, respiratory rate, blood oxygen levels, and skin temperature. The WHOOP tracker also features a smart alarm designed to prevent grogginess by gently waking you up during the ideal moment in your sleep cycle. However, it is a subscription-based service, so you have to pay monthly charges to access the data.

The Ultrahuman Ring Air is another smart ring that tracks sleep. It is lighter than the Oura Ring and does not require a subscription. It has a PPG sensor, a non-contact medical-grade skin temperature sensor, 6-axis motion sensors, and LEDs for heart rate monitoring and oxygen saturation.

The Biostrap Kairos is a lightweight wrist-worn band with a PPG sensor and accelerometer to track your heart rate, respiration, and HRV. It tracks sleep by breaking it down into awake, light, and deep sleep (with REM to be added soon) and combines your biometrics to give you a sleep score. It also surveys you each morning on sleep quality and how refreshed you feel. However, it is designed for researchers, medical staff, and organizations, so it is unavailable for most people to buy.

They can track health data throughout the day, including heart rate and body temperature

Wearable technology has been rapidly expanding, with the global market for such devices contributing $36 billion to the world economy in 2020. This includes fitness trackers, which can be worn on the wrist to track health data throughout the day and during sleep. These devices can monitor sleep duration and quality, as well as other health indicators like heart rate, body temperature, and even breathing.

Actigraphy is the method used by these devices to track movements and measure sleep. They use motion detectors called accelerometers to detect movement, with the theory that movement equals wakefulness and a lack of movement equals sleep. While this technology has been around for decades, it is important to note that it does have limitations and a high margin of error. For example, wake time is often the most difficult for actigraphs to get right, as periods of no movement will almost always register as sleep. This can result in an overestimation of sleep time if the wearer does not move enough while awake.

Additionally, different trackers use various algorithms to translate raw data into statistics, which can lead to discrepancies between devices. The algorithms and technology used greatly impact the accuracy of the data, and even factors like a bumpy car ride or a plush carpet can affect the readings. Therefore, it is recommended to use these devices as a general guide rather than an exact measurement of sleep time and quality, especially if one suspects they have a sleep disorder.

Despite these limitations, fitness trackers can still provide valuable insights into overall health and activity levels. They can track heart rate trends, monitor energy expenditure or calories burned, and even provide breathing data. Some trackers also have additional features like temperature sensors and bioimpedance sensors, which can measure the electrical resistance of the skin. This allows for a more comprehensive understanding of an individual's health and can be especially useful for those with specific health conditions or goals.

They can be lightweight and comfortable, with some being screenless

Wearable sleep trackers are a popular choice for those looking to monitor their sleep patterns. These devices can be worn on the wrist, hand, or finger, and typically fall into the category of rings, wristbands, or smartwatches. One of the advantages of these devices is that they tend to be lightweight and comfortable, making them ideal for wearing during sleep without causing any discomfort or disruption to your rest.

The Oura Ring, for example, has been praised for its lightweight and comfortable design. It comes in a range of styles and finishes, allowing it to be discreetly worn with different clothing and accessory choices. The Oura Ring offers accurate sleep tracking and useful guidance, although its activity tracking has been noted to require some improvement. Similarly, the Ultrahuman Ring Air has been described as lighter than the Oura Ring and does not require a subscription, making it a more affordable option.

The Whoop wristband, another popular sleep tracker, is also lightweight and comfortable. Its woven design allows it to be worn all day and during sleep without causing any inconvenience. The Whoop wristband is also waterproof and has a detachable battery pack, making it convenient for charging on the go. It collects a wide range of data, including heart rate, respiratory rate, blood oxygen levels, and skin temperature.

In addition to rings and wristbands, smartwatches are another option for sleep tracking. Smartwatches like the Fitbit and the Google Pixel Watch 2 have been designed to be lightweight and compact, ensuring comfort during sleep. These devices provide insights into sleep patterns and offer features such as nightly trends, bedtime reminders, and silent alarms.

When choosing a sleep tracker, it is important to consider not only the comfort and lightweight design but also the type of data you want to collect. Some devices focus solely on sleep tracking, while others offer additional features such as health and fitness tracking, providing a more comprehensive insight into your overall well-being. Ultimately, the best sleep tracker is the one that suits your individual needs and preferences, helping you to achieve a better understanding of your sleep habits and, consequently, a better night's rest.

They can be used with other garments, like sports bras or compression tops

Sleep trackers can be a great way to identify patterns in your sleep and improve your sleep quality. While some trackers are designed to be worn on the wrist, others can be worn on different parts of the body, offering more versatility. The WHOOP sleep tracker, for example, can be worn as a wristband, but it can also be attached to other garments, like a sports bra or compression top. This feature enhances its versatility and makes it more comfortable for users who prefer not to wear it on their wrist.

The WHOOP tracker is a subscription-based service that provides detailed sleep data. It monitors various metrics, including heart rate, respiratory rate, blood oxygen levels, and skin temperature. This data helps users understand their sleep patterns and make informed decisions to optimize their sleep. Additionally, the WHOOP tracker includes a smart alarm feature, designed to gently wake the user during the ideal moment in their sleep cycle, aiming to prevent grogginess in the morning.

The ability to attach the tracker to a sports bra or compression top can be particularly useful for those who engage in physical activities or workouts. It allows users to track their heart rate, respiratory rate, and other metrics during exercise, providing valuable insights into their overall health and fitness. This dual functionality of the WHOOP tracker makes it a versatile tool for those interested in both sleep tracking and fitness monitoring.

Compared to wrist-based trackers, wearing the WHOOP tracker on a sports bra or compression top may offer a more comfortable option for those with smaller wrists or those who find wristbands restrictive. It also eliminates the need to wear multiple devices, as the same tracker can be used for both sleep and fitness tracking. This versatility can simplify the user's routine and provide a more holistic view of their health data.

In conclusion, the option to use the WHOOP tracker with garments like sports bras or compression tops enhances its functionality and appeal to a wider range of users. It demonstrates the device's versatility, allowing users to choose the most comfortable and convenient way to collect valuable sleep and fitness data. This adaptability is a significant advantage, contributing to a more positive and personalized experience for those seeking to improve their sleep and overall well-being.

They can be used alongside a sleep-tracking app for added insights

Sleep-tracking wristbands can be used alongside a sleep-tracking app for added insights. Many sleep-tracking wristbands have their own apps, which can provide a wealth of information. For example, the Oura Ring app adapts to your sleep habits to determine realistic bedtime goals, rather than pushing you towards a generic sleep schedule. The Whoop wristband also has an app that provides a large amount of biometric data, including a daily readiness score and daytime stress measurements. The app also includes a library of meditations.

The Ultrahuman Ring Air has an app that notifies you of the best times to get daylight, drink stimulants, and go to bed for your circadian rhythm. The app also provides informative explanations for each element of sleep measured, although the advice varies in usefulness.

Sleep-tracking apps can also be used to compare the accuracy of sleep-tracking wristbands. For example, one source kept a manual sleep diary to see if the Oura Ring could accurately record when they went to bed, fell asleep, woke up in the night, and woke up in the morning. They also compared the heart-rate data from the wristband with that of a heart-rate sensor.

It is important to note that the accuracy of sleep-tracking wristbands can vary. For example, wake time has been found to be the most difficult for actigraphs to get right, as periods of no movement will almost always register as sleep. Additionally, if you have or think you have a sleep disorder, it is not recommended to trust actigraphy devices. In that case, it is better to visit a sleep clinic and get a PSG test done.

Frequently asked questions