Sleep Tracking Apps: Reliable Or Not?

Sleep trackers have become increasingly popular, with one in three Americans having used a sleep-tracking device. While these devices can provide a lot of information about sleep habits, their accuracy has been called into question. Sleep trackers use algorithms to estimate sleep based on body movements and sometimes heart rate data. Research suggests that these devices are good at detecting sleep but less effective at determining wake periods, which may lead to an overestimation of total sleep time. The accuracy of sleep trackers also depends on the technology used, with some performing better on wearables than phones. Overall, while sleep trackers can be useful for gaining insights into sleep patterns, they should not be relied upon for precise medical diagnoses.

Sleep trackers are good at detecting sleep but less so at detecting wakefulness

Sleep trackers are becoming increasingly popular, with some estimates claiming that one in three Americans have used a sleep-tracking device. These devices can be worn on the wrist or clipped to a pillow, and they can provide a lot of information about our sleep habits. However, the question of their accuracy remains a concern.

Research has shown that sleep trackers are only accurate 78% of the time when identifying sleep versus wakefulness, and this accuracy drops to around 38% when estimating how long it took participants to fall asleep. In addition, sleep trackers may overestimate the overall time a wearer spends asleep each night. This is because they rely primarily on measuring body movements, and people in the early stages of sleep move similarly to when they are awake. Heart rate data can help improve accuracy, but even devices that track heart rate may underestimate the amount of deep sleep obtained.

Despite these limitations, sleep trackers can still be useful for people who want to gain insight into their sleep habits and make lifestyle changes to improve their sleep quality. They can help users keep track of bedtimes and wake times and detect interrupted sleep. Over time, as more data is collected, the trackers can become more accurate in their predictions.

Sleep trackers are more accurate when they use data from a wearable device

Sleep trackers have become increasingly popular, with one in three Americans having used a sleep-tracking device. While these devices provide plenty of sleep data, their accuracy is questionable. Sleep trackers don't directly measure sleep but instead rely on measuring inactivity as a surrogate for estimating sleep. This means that they often overestimate the total sleep time and struggle with precise sleep stage identification.

However, sleep trackers that use data from wearable devices are more accurate than those that don't. Wearable sleep trackers can employ various technologies to detect sleep more accurately. For example, optical heart-rate monitoring uses tiny LEDs in the band to shine a light through the skin and capture blood flow. As the rate changes, the light reflecting back to the device changes, and this information is combined with movement data to deliver a sleep report. Accelerometers, which detect movement, are another common technology used in wearables. While these may be less effective on foam mattresses due to their motion isolation properties, they perform more accurately on wearables than on non-wearable sleep trackers.

Additionally, different heart rate patterns occur during various sleep stages, and advancements in technology have helped wearable devices better detect these patterns. Some advanced wearables incorporate additional sensors, such as temperature sensors, electrodermal activity sensors, and ambient light sensors, to further refine sleep tracking. These sensors measure skin temperature, detect changes in skin conductance, and help determine the light conditions during sleep, respectively. The data from these sensors is then processed using proprietary algorithms to estimate sleep metrics.

Despite the improvements in accuracy that wearables offer, it's important to remember that sleep trackers are not a substitute for medical advice. If you have concerns about your sleep quality, it's best to consult a health practitioner. Sleep trackers should be used as tools for self-awareness and gaining insights into your sleep patterns. They can help you recognize trends and make adjustments to your sleep habits accordingly.

Sleep trackers can help you recognise patterns in your sleep habits

Sleep trackers can be a great way to help you recognise patterns in your sleep habits. They can provide insights into your sleep duration and quality, and some can even detect interrupted sleep, letting you know when you wake up during the night. While they don't directly measure sleep, they estimate sleep by tracking your body movements and sometimes your heart rate data. This means they can be a useful tool for understanding your sleep patterns and making adjustments to improve your sleep quality.

Sleep trackers work by using algorithms to estimate how much time you spend asleep based on your body movements and, in some cases, your heart rate. The apps interpret the data collected by the trackers to provide you with information about your sleep habits. Some trackers also allow you to input lifestyle factors such as caffeine intake, meal times, and stress levels, which can further help you identify patterns affecting your sleep.

The accuracy of sleep trackers has been the subject of several studies. While they may not be as precise as medical sleep studies, research suggests that consumer sleep trackers perform as well as, or even better than, actigraphy in detecting sleep and wake states. However, it's important to note that sleep trackers may be less accurate in determining wake periods, potentially overestimating the total sleep time. Additionally, they may struggle to accurately detect different sleep stages.

Despite some limitations, sleep trackers can still provide valuable insights into your sleep habits. They can help you keep track of your bedtimes and wake-up times, and some can even provide a "sleep score" to give you an idea of how well you slept. Over time, as more data is collected, the trackers can become more attuned to your sleep patterns, making their insights more useful.

It's worth noting that the accuracy of sleep trackers can depend on the technology used and the algorithms employed. Two apps using the same technology may still produce different sleep reports. Additionally, the accuracy may improve with time as the app collects more data and learns your sleep patterns.

Sleep trackers are not great at telling users what to do with the results

Sleep trackers often use algorithms to estimate sleep patterns based on body movements and, sometimes, heart rate data. However, as people move during all stages of sleep, movement provides limited clues about the specific sleep stage a person is in. Additionally, sleep devices often fail to differentiate between sleep stages based on motion alone, and their algorithms are not always known or validated, making it challenging to determine their accuracy.

The accuracy of sleep trackers also depends on the technology used. Accelerometer-based apps, for instance, have shown poor correlations with polysomnography (PSG) sleep substages. PSG is a gold-standard sleep study performed in a lab that tracks brain waves, heart rate, breathing, blood oxygen levels, and body and eye movements during sleep. Sleep trackers that rely solely on motion data may struggle to detect sleep in people with insomnia who remain very still while trying to fall asleep.

While some sleep trackers provide lifestyle prompts, such as inputting information about caffeine intake or stress levels, they may not offer specific advice tailored to an individual's sleep data. The interpretation of data is crucial, and the same technology can yield varying sleep reports depending on the app. Over time, as more data is collected, sleep trackers can become more attuned to an individual's sleep patterns and potentially offer more personalized insights. However, currently, the accuracy and precision of sleep trackers are still being refined.

Sleep trackers are not accurate for people with insomnia

Sleep trackers have become increasingly popular, with one in three Americans having used a sleep-tracking device. While these devices can provide insights into sleep patterns and durations, they have limitations and may not be accurate for everyone, especially those with insomnia.

Sleep trackers rely on measuring body movement and sometimes heart rate data to estimate sleep stages and duration. However, people with insomnia tend to remain very still in bed while trying to fall asleep. As a result, sleep trackers may struggle to differentiate between sleep and wakefulness in this population, leading to inaccurate readings.

Additionally, sleep trackers may not accurately identify sleep stages even in healthy individuals. A study of heart rate sleep trackers showed that two consumer devices underestimated deep sleep by up to 46 minutes. This inaccuracy can be concerning for people with insomnia who are already anxious about their sleep patterns. The over-attention to "sleep numbers" can further interfere with sleep and even worsen mental health issues.

While sleep trackers can provide some insights, they should not replace medical advice. If you are experiencing insomnia or other sleep concerns, it is essential to consult a trained health professional. Sleep trackers can be used as a tool to complement the advice and treatment provided by a healthcare provider.

In summary, while sleep trackers offer a convenient way to monitor sleep, they may not be accurate for people with insomnia due to their limited ability to differentiate between sleep and wakefulness based on motion and heart rate alone. It is crucial to interpret the data from sleep trackers with caution and seek professional guidance for managing insomnia or other sleep disorders.

Frequently asked questions