Sleep Deprivation: A Student Epidemic?

Sleep is a critical component of overall health, and insufficient sleep is linked to obesity, depression, type 2 diabetes, and heart disease. Poor sleep can also cause car crashes, and the CDC estimates that over 6,000 fatal crashes a year involve a drowsy driver. According to the CDC, more than two-thirds of high school-aged adolescents aren't getting enough sleep, and the situation is worsening. The CDC's findings are based on results from the Youth Risk Behavior Surveys (YRBS) administered in 2015, which found that 72.7% of high school students reported insufficient sleep, with about 20% sleeping fewer than 6 hours a night. Similarly, a 2019 study showed that 70% of high schoolers aren't getting enough sleep, and a 2018 study revealed that 73% of high school students are not meeting the recommended sleep duration.

Insufficient sleep is linked to obesity, diabetes, and heart disease

Sleep is an essential part of our lives, and getting a good night's rest is crucial for maintaining optimal health. Unfortunately, many students are not getting enough sleep, with over two-thirds of high schoolers and more than half of middle schoolers reporting insufficient sleep. This lack of sleep has been linked to various health issues, including obesity, diabetes, and heart disease.

Obesity

Obesity is a significant concern for individuals who are not getting enough sleep. Sleep loss creates a hormone imbalance that increases feelings of hunger and promotes weight gain. Two key hormones, leptin and ghrelin, are responsible for regulating appetite. However, when we don't get enough sleep, the production of these hormones is altered, leading to increased hunger. Additionally, sleep deprivation is associated with growth hormone deficiency and elevated cortisol levels, which have also been linked to obesity.

Diabetes

Diabetes, particularly type 2 diabetes, is the most common form of diabetes and is affected by sleep. Unstable blood sugar levels and diabetes-related symptoms can lead to insomnia and fatigue. High blood sugar can cause frequent urination, headaches, increased thirst, and tiredness, all of which can disrupt sleep. On the other hand, low blood sugar can cause nightmares, sweating, and confusion. Sleep deprivation also raises the risk of developing insulin resistance, a key factor in type 2 diabetes.

Heart Disease

Heart problems are a leading cause of illness and death, and sleep deprivation has been recognised as a contributing factor. Sleep provides the body with time to restore and recharge, playing a crucial role in maintaining physical health. During non-rapid eye movement (NREM) sleep, heart rate slows down, blood pressure drops, and breathing stabilises, reducing stress on the heart. However, without sufficient sleep, individuals don't spend enough time in the deep stages of NREM sleep, increasing the risk of high blood pressure, high cholesterol, heart attack, and stroke.

The percentage of students not getting enough sleep varies by state, sex, age, and race

Sleep deprivation among students is a widespread issue, with rates of insufficient sleep highest among high school students. The percentage of students not getting enough sleep varies not only by state but also by sex, age, and race.

State

In 2021, the percentage of high school students not getting enough sleep ranged from 71% in South Dakota to 84% in Pennsylvania. Pennsylvania reported the highest rate of insufficient sleep for high schoolers at 83.9%. Ten other states reported rates of 80% or above.

Sex

More female students than male students reported not getting enough sleep. Among high school students, 80% of females and 70% of males did not get enough sleep.

Age

Older students are more likely to suffer from insufficient sleep. The percentage of high school students who do not get enough sleep was highest among 12th-grade students at 84%.

Race

Racial disparities in sleep deprivation are also evident, with Black students being the most affected. The Youth Risk Behavior Survey found that 84% of Black students did not get enough sleep.

The prevalence of insufficient sleep among students has significant implications for their health, well-being, and academic performance. Addressing these disparities is crucial to ensure the overall well-being and success of students across different states, sexes, ages, and racial groups.

Female students are more likely to not get enough sleep than male students

A study by the US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) found that more than 2 out of 3 high school-aged adolescents aren't getting enough sleep, with the situation worsening over time. The findings are based on results from the Youth Risk Behavior Surveys (YRBS) conducted in 2015, which asked students about their sleep habits on an average school night. The CDC recommends at least 9-12 hours of sleep for children aged 6-12 and 8-10 hours for those aged 13-18.

Among middle school students, 57.8% reported insufficient sleep, with 12% sleeping fewer than 6 hours a night. The situation was worse for high school students, with 72.7% not getting enough sleep and about 20% sleeping fewer than 6 hours. Notably, female students fared worse than their male counterparts, with 59.6% of middle school girls and 75.6% of high school girls not getting enough sleep compared to 56% and 69.9% of boys in the respective age groups.

The trend of female students experiencing more sleep deprivation than male students persists into college. A study of college students at two large midwestern universities found that 26.4% experienced insomnia, with a higher prevalence among women (81.6%) than men. Another study of 7,626 students from six universities found that 62% met the criteria for poor sleep, with female students (64%) more affected than males (57%).

Several factors contribute to the gender disparity in sleep deprivation among students. One study found that female college students went to bed and rose earlier, had longer sleep latency, more awakenings, and poorer sleep quality than male students. Biological factors, such as hormonal changes and menstruation, may also play a role. Additionally, gender-based responsibilities, such as caregiving, more often disrupt sleep for women. Social and cultural expectations, as well as family and work responsibilities, further contribute to the gender gap in sleep duration.

Students with depression and ADHD have higher odds of insomnia

Sleep is essential for students' physical and mental health and academic performance. However, a significant number of students across various levels of education are not getting enough sleep.

Middle and High School Students

According to the US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), more than 2 out of 3 high school-aged adolescents aren't getting enough sleep. The situation is similar for middle school-aged children, with 57.8% reporting insufficient sleep. The recommended amount of sleep for high school students is 8 hours each day, and anything less is considered insufficient sleep or short sleep duration.

College Students

Insomnia is prevalent among college students, with at least a quarter experiencing it. A study by Mbous et al. found that 26.4% of college students experienced insomnia, with 41.2% and 15.8% exhibiting symptoms of depression and ADHD, respectively.

The study by Mbous et al. also revealed that students with depression and ADHD had significantly higher odds of insomnia. The adjusted odds ratio for students with depression was 9.54, and for students with ADHD, it was 3.48. This indicates a strong association between insomnia and mental health conditions.

Implications and Interventions

The high prevalence of insomnia among students, especially those with depression and ADHD, demands serious consideration of mental health when addressing sleep quality issues. Policy efforts and interventions should focus on primary and secondary prevention programs that enforce sleep education, particularly for students with mental illnesses.

Additionally, addressing mental health and insomnia concomitantly is crucial. This includes helping students develop better time management skills for studying, working, and leisure to cope with the increasing demands of student life.

Furthermore, promoting healthy behaviors such as physical activity on campuses can significantly improve students' lifestyle and sleep quality, as physical activity has been shown to mitigate the effect of mental health on insomnia.

Sleep deprivation can lead to drowsiness while driving and depression-like symptoms

Sleep deprivation is a major cause of motor vehicle accidents, and it can impair the human brain as much as inebriation can. According to the United States Department of Transportation, 23% of adults have fallen asleep while driving, with twice as many male drivers than female drivers admitting to having done so. Sleep deprivation has been proven to affect driving ability in four main areas: it impairs coordination, causes longer reaction times, impairs judgment, and impairs memory and the ability to retain information.

In addition to the dangers of drowsy driving, sleep deprivation can also lead to depression-like symptoms. Research has shown that insomnia is prevalent among college students, with at least a quarter experiencing it. Insomnia is strongly associated with depression, with 78.2% of students with insomnia also experiencing depression. The odds of insomnia were 9.54 times higher among students with depression than those without. Furthermore, the direct consequences of poor sleep among college students include increased tension, irritability, depression, confusion, reduced life satisfaction, and poor academic performance.

Frequently asked questions