Dreaming Without Rem Sleep: Is It Possible?

Dreaming is not exclusive to REM sleep. While it is true that the discovery of REM sleep in the 1950s led to the popular misconception that dreaming only happens during this stage, research has since shown that dreaming can occur during the early, non-REM stages of sleep as well.

REM sleep is the fourth and final stage of the sleep cycle, which typically lasts about 90 minutes. The first three stages are non-REM sleep. During REM sleep, the eyes move rapidly, the heart rate speeds up, and the breathing becomes irregular. The brain is highly active during this stage, and the body experiences a temporary loss of muscle tone.

Dreams that occur during REM sleep tend to be more vivid, elaborate, hallucinogenic, and emotional. However, it is important to note that the function of REM sleep remains a matter of debate among sleep researchers. While deprivation of REM sleep in humans for up to two weeks has shown little to no obvious effect on behavior, the function of non-REM sleep is generally accepted to be, at least in part, restorative.

Dreaming during non-REM sleep

It is possible to dream during non-rapid eye movement (NREM) sleep. However, the dreams that occur during this stage tend to be more abstract and less vivid than those that occur during REM sleep.

Research on non-REM dreams

Research from Aalto University and the University of Wisconsin has demonstrated that dreaming during NREM sleep is possible. In their study, researchers used a TMS-EEG device to examine brain activity in participants during NREM sleep. They found that participants who dreamt during NREM sleep had brain activity that more closely resembled that of people who were awake, compared to those who did not dream during NREM sleep.

Another study, published in the *Frontiers in Psychology*, found that lucid dreaming can occur during both REM and non-REM sleep. A lucid dream is when you know you’re dreaming during a dream. However, lucid dreams mostly occur during REM sleep.

Differences between REM and non-REM dreams

Dreams that occur during REM sleep tend to be more vivid, complex, and emotional than those that occur during non-REM sleep. One reason for this may be that the brain is more active during REM sleep, which allows for more intense and elaborate dreams. Additionally, the body is paralysed during REM sleep, which may contribute to the feeling of being immersed in a dream.

Dreams that occur during non-REM sleep, on the other hand, tend to be more conceptual and less vivid. They may also be shorter and less likely to be remembered than dreams that occur during REM sleep.

The role of REM and non-REM sleep

Both REM and non-REM sleep are important for overall health and well-being. REM sleep is important for learning and memory, while non-REM sleep is when the body repairs and regenerates tissues, builds bone and muscle, and strengthens the immune system.

Differences between REM and non-REM dreams

Dreams can occur during both REM and non-REM sleep. However, there are differences in the nature of dreams during these two types of sleep. REM sleep is often associated with more vivid, complex, and emotionally intense dreams, while non-REM dreams tend to be less vivid and more conceptual.

Recall Rates

Recall rates for dreams are significantly higher during REM sleep, with around 80% of dreams being recalled, compared to only about 40% for non-REM sleep. However, recall rates during non-REM sleep vary depending on the specific stage, with dream recall being highest during the first stage of non-REM sleep and lowest during the deep sleep stage.

Dream Length

REM sleep dreams tend to be longer than non-REM dreams. This is one of the most consistent findings in dream research, with multiple studies showing that REM dreams have higher word counts and are more story-like in structure.

Dream Characteristics

REM dreams are typically rated as more intense, bizarre, vivid, and emotionally engaging than non-REM dreams, which are often more thought-like and conceptual. However, some studies suggest that these differences may be due to the longer length of REM dreams, and when controlling for dream length, the differences between REM and non-REM dreams diminish or disappear.

Time of Night Effects

Some characteristics of dreams change over the course of the night, regardless of the sleep stage. For example, dream reports tend to become longer, more dream-like, and more bizarre as the night progresses. However, some changes are specific to REM or non-REM sleep. For example, REM dreams show selective increases in emotionality, while non-REM dreams show a decrease in directed thought.

Clinical Implications

The study of REM and non-REM dreams has clinical implications, particularly for our understanding of sleep disorders and mental health conditions. For example, graph analysis of dream reports has been used to identify thought disturbances in psychosis and to distinguish between patients with Alzheimer's disease and healthy controls.

While dreams can occur during both REM and non-REM sleep, there are clear differences in the characteristics of dreams during these two types of sleep. REM sleep is associated with more vivid, complex, and emotionally intense dreams, while non-REM dreams tend to be shorter and more thought-like. These differences have important implications for our understanding of sleep and its role in cognitive function and mental health.

REM sleep and memory consolidation

The function of REM sleep remains a mystery, with no clear consensus on its purpose. However, one of the most popular theories is that REM sleep plays a role in memory consolidation.

Evidence for REM Sleep's Role in Memory Consolidation

Several studies have found that REM sleep is associated with memory consolidation. For example, one study found that participants awakened from REM sleep recalled elaborate, vivid, hallucinogenic, and emotional dreams, whereas participants awakened during non-REM sleep reported fewer dreams, which were more conceptual, less vivid, and less emotion-laden.

Another study found that sleep has a positive impact on learning, with participants who slept after learning a task performing better than those who stayed awake. Furthermore, some researchers have found that REM sleep is associated with the replay of neuronal activity seen during prior learning episodes, suggesting that REM sleep may be involved in memory consolidation.

Evidence Against REM Sleep's Role in Memory Consolidation

However, there is also evidence that contradicts the theory that REM sleep plays a role in memory consolidation. For example, one study found that deprivation of REM sleep in humans for up to two weeks had little to no obvious effect on behavior. Similarly, patients taking certain antidepressants that suppress REM sleep show no obvious ill effects, even after months or years of treatment.

Additionally, some studies have found that non-REM sleep, rather than REM sleep, may be more important for memory consolidation. For instance, one study found that non-REM sleep is necessary for the healing of muscles, the promotion of growth and development, and the boosting of immunity.

While there is some evidence to support the theory that REM sleep plays a role in memory consolidation, there is also contradictory evidence, and the function of REM sleep remains a subject of debate among researchers.

REM sleep and emotional processing

REM sleep plays a key role in regulating emotions. Sleep deprivation is followed by the rebound of REM sleep and slow-wave sleep in the following nights. Clinical evidence suggests that sleep has a role in regulating our emotional brain-state since sleep impairment corresponds to affective dysfunction. REM sleep dreaming plays a crucial role in modulating people's emotions. REM sleep appears to be essential to our ability to cope with emotional stress in everyday life. However, when daily stress is insufficiently regulated, it may result in mental health problems and sleep disturbances too. Not only does emotion impact sleep, but there is also evidence that sleep plays a key role in regulating emotion. Emotional events during waking hours affect sleep, and the quality and amount of sleep influences the way we react to these events impacting our general well-being.

REM sleep and brain development

Sleep is one of the primary activities of the brain during early development and plays a critical role in healthy cognitive and psychosocial development in early life. The early years of life are characterised by dramatic developmental changes, and sleep helps to facilitate this transition from newborn to childhood.

Sleep Stages

Sleep is divided into two distinct stages: REM (rapid-eye movement) sleep and non-REM sleep. Each state is associated with a distinct pattern of brain electrical activity.

REM Sleep

REM sleep is often referred to as "dream sleep" and is characterised by desynchronised cortical activity with low-voltage and high-frequency electroencephalogram. During this stage, the mental activity of human REM sleep is associated with dreaming, and the absence of skeletal muscle tone means that people cannot move their body and limbs.

REM sleep is thought to play a role in:

• Consolidating and integrating memories
• Developing the central nervous system
• Maintaining and establishing new connections, particularly during early brain development

Non-REM Sleep

Non-REM sleep is believed to function primarily as a restful and restorative sleep phase. It is associated with a time of relatively low brain activity and is usually divided into three stages:

• Stage 1: The lightest stage of sleep where a person is still alert enough to be awakened easily.
• Stage 2: Heart rate and breathing slow down even more, and body temperature drops.
• Stage 3: Deep, restorative sleep that is important for healing muscles, promoting growth and development, and boosting immunity.

Sleep and Brain Development

Research has shown that sleep plays a critical role in learning and memory, emotional regulation, and related brain structure development.

Learning and Memory

Two types of sleep have been shown to be associated with different memory processing:

• Non-REM sleep, especially slow-wave sleep, is associated with the reactivation of hippocampal-neocortical circuits activated during a waking learning period.
• REM sleep is responsible for the consolidation of new learning into long-term memory.

Emotional Regulation

Sleep plays a critical role in mental health and psychosocial adjustment across the lifespan. A growing body of research suggests that inadequate sleep leads to more negative and less positive emotions. During REM sleep, a hyperlimbic and hypoactive dorsolateral prefrontal activation, and a normal function of the medial prefrontal cortex may explain its adaptive role in coping with emotional events.

General Cognitive and Brain Structure Development

Several studies have examined the relationship between sleep and general cognitive development or language development in infants and toddlers. Some key findings include:

• A greater number of awakenings after sleep onset in 10-month-old infants were negatively correlated with the scores of the Bayley Scales of Infant and Toddler Development second edition (BSID-II) Mental Development Index (MDI).
• Infants who had either greater sleep efficiency or longer proportions of sleep at night were associated with better cognitive problem-solving skills as measured by the Ages and Stages Questionnaire.
• Frequent nighttime awakenings reported by caregivers are associated with a lower MDI in BSID-I in toddlers between 12 and 30 months.
• A poor sleep consolidation during the first 2 years of life may be a risk factor for language learning in later childhood.

A Hypothetical Model

A hypothetical model has been presented to explain the dynamic relationship of REM sleep and non-REM sleep with different processes of brain maturation. This model suggests that:

• REM sleep provides the endogenous neural stimulation that the child is not yet able to achieve exogenously during the very early stages of life.
• Non-REM sleep seems more functionally important for later brain maturation, by regulating synaptic homeostasis.

Understanding the links between sleep and brain development is important, as REM sleep and non-REM sleep seem to contribute to different aspects of brain maturation. If children have sleep problems, REM sleep and non-REM sleep are likely to have different consequences for their developing brain, depending on their age.

Frequently asked questions