Activity Trackers: Deep Sleep Secrets Revealed

Sleep trackers have become increasingly popular as more people are concerned about getting enough sleep. These trackers come in several forms, from wearable devices like smartwatches, rings, and headbands to devices that can be slipped under a sheet. Sleep trackers can provide a wealth of data, from sleep duration to sleep efficiency, restfulness, REM, deep sleep, and latency. While they can collect a lot of information about sleep habits, they don't directly measure sleep. Instead, they often estimate sleep based on body movements and, in some cases, heart rate changes.

Heart rate and sleep cycles

Sleep trackers are devices that monitor your sleep habits. They come in several forms, from wearable smartwatches to headbands that provide biofeedback, rings, or devices slipped under your sheet. Sleep trackers do not directly measure sleep. Instead, they often measure inactivity as a surrogate for estimating sleep. Most sleep-tracking devices make some guesstimate as to how much you’re actually sleeping.

Some sleep trackers estimate REM sleep in addition to deep and light sleep stages by measuring heart rate. Heart rate and respiration rates are known to vary during sleep, but they are closely related to each sleep stage since the autonomic nervous system significantly affects both. Watches that incorporate heart rate data tend to be slightly more accurate when measuring sleep duration because heart rate fluctuates during different sleep stages. However, even devices that track heart rate may not be entirely accurate due to the limited research on them and the differences between each device.

The Oura Ring, for example, tracks sleep cycles, total sleep time, resting heart rate, heart rate variability, and movement. The Apple Watch Series 10 has FDA-cleared sleep apnea detection, and the Health app can provide information about breathing disturbances throughout the night. The Ultrahuman app notifies you of a good bedtime window for your circadian rhythm and provides a Sleep Index, a score out of 100 for each night's rest based on factors including sleep efficiency, temperature, restfulness, consistency, total sleep, and heart rate drop.

While sleep trackers can be a helpful tool to recognize patterns in your sleep habits, they are not a substitute for medical advice. If you have concerns about the quality of your sleep, it is recommended to consult a health practitioner.

Actigraphy and body movement

Actigraphy is a technique used to measure body movement and rest patterns. It is a type of wearable sleep test that uses an actigraph device to track body movements and identify sleep patterns. The actigraph device is usually worn on the wrist or ankle and resembles a wristwatch. It contains an accelerometer that records movement, a data storage unit, and a programmable timing mechanism.

Actigraphy is often used to help diagnose and monitor sleep disorders, such as insomnia, and can be used in conjunction with other sleep tests such as sleep logs or overnight sleep tests. By tracking body movements, actigraphy can determine when an individual falls asleep, wakes up, and falls back asleep, as well as the total sleep time. It identifies the absence of movement as sleep and can help healthcare providers identify underlying conditions that may affect the sleep-wake cycle.

Actigraphy is considered more accurate than sleep logs but less accurate than polysomnography, which measures brain activity, breathing, and oxygen levels. Actigraphy is quite accurate for healthy individuals but less so for those with fragmented sleep, reduced sleep time, or restless sleep. It is important to note that actigraphy does not directly measure sleep but instead relies on interpreting movements to make calculations about sleep parameters.

Some sleep trackers, like the Oura Ring, also incorporate heart rate data and smart sensors to provide deeper insights into sleep patterns and efficiency. These additional data points can enhance the accuracy of sleep tracking and provide explanations for the numbers presented. However, the accuracy of these devices may vary, and further research is needed to validate their effectiveness in measuring sleep.

Accuracy and limitations

While activity trackers can collect a lot of information about sleep habits, they don't measure sleep directly. Instead, they often measure inactivity as a surrogate for estimating sleep. Most sleep-tracking devices make some guesstimate as to how much one is actually sleeping. For exact data about sleep habits, one would have to do a medical sleep study, which monitors brain waves to analyse the stages of sleep cycled through during the night. This is known as polysomnography (PSG), which is considered the gold standard of sleep tracking.

Compared to PSG, sleep trackers are only accurate 78% of the time when identifying sleep versus wakefulness. This accuracy drops to around 38% when estimating how long it took participants to fall asleep. Watches that incorporate heart rate data tend to be slightly more accurate when measuring sleep duration because heart rate fluctuates during different sleep stages. However, even in devices that do track heart rate, many experts are still uncertain of their accuracy due to limited research and differences between each device. For example, one study of heart rate sleep trackers showed that two consumer devices tended to underestimate the amount of deep sleep by as much as 46 minutes.

Sleep trackers can be useful for helping one recognise patterns in their sleep habits. They can help one reflect on their sleep patterns and make changes to their habits. For instance, one might feel sluggish when sleeping from 10 pm to 6 am but feel more energetic when sleeping from 11 pm to 7 am. One might also sleep better when their bedroom is cooler or on days they exercise. Sleep trackers can provide data on such patterns, often with user-friendly graphs or reports that make it easy to spot trends.

Despite their benefits, sleep trackers could cause unwanted anxiety for some. Additionally, tracking sleep does not necessarily result in better sleep. Changing habits based on what one learns from sleep tracking is key.

Sleep patterns and user experience

Sleep trackers can be a great way to gain insight into your sleep patterns and help you understand your sleep quality. They can provide a wealth of data, from sleep duration to specific sleep stages like REM, light, and deep sleep. This data can be used to identify trends and patterns in your sleep habits, which can guide you in making adjustments for better sleep. For example, you might discover that you feel more energetic when you sleep from 11 p.m. to 7 a.m. or that your bedroom temperature affects your sleep quality.

Most sleep trackers are in the form of a watch or a ring, and they use various methods to estimate your sleep patterns. Some common techniques include monitoring body movements and inactivity, measuring heart rate changes, and detecting respiration rates. While these methods can provide valuable insights, it's important to note that sleep trackers do not directly measure sleep. Instead, they make estimations based on surrogate indicators.

The accuracy of sleep trackers has been a topic of discussion among experts. While some studies have shown promising results, such as the Fitbit offering impressive accuracy for its cost, others have found discrepancies in the data. For example, a study on heart rate sleep trackers showed that certain devices underestimated deep sleep duration by up to 46 minutes. Polysomnography (PSG) tests, which monitor brain waves, heart rate, breathing, and other parameters, remain the gold standard for sleep tracking.

Despite the limitations in accuracy, sleep trackers can still be a useful tool for users. They often provide user-friendly graphs and reports that make it easier to understand your sleep patterns. Additionally, some trackers offer features like sleep scores, bedtime suggestions, and notifications for optimal daylight exposure or stimulant consumption. These features can help users make sense of the data and take appropriate actions to improve their sleep habits.

However, it's important to approach sleep tracking with a degree of flexibility. While the data can provide insights, it should not be the sole determinant of your sleep quality. Tracking sleep, like tracking eating habits, does not automatically translate to better sleep. The key lies in interpreting the data and making conscious changes to your habits. Additionally, excessive preoccupation with sleep data can lead to anxiety and low mood, especially for individuals with chronic insomnia. Therefore, it's recommended to consult a health practitioner if you have concerns about your sleep quality.

Comparison to medical sleep studies

Sleep trackers are increasingly popular, with some estimates claiming that one in three Americans have used a sleep-tracking device. However, it is important to note that these devices do not directly measure sleep. Instead, they often estimate sleep by measuring inactivity. For more exact data about sleep habits, a medical sleep study is required.

Medical sleep studies, also known as polysomnography (PSG) tests, are performed in a lab or sleep lab by medical technicians, technologists, assistants, and nurses. These tests involve monitoring and recording various body systems and typically occur during a person's regular sleep time. Electrodes are attached to the scalp and skin to track brain waves, heart rate, breathing, blood oxygen levels, body movements, and eye movements. PSG is considered the gold standard for sleep studies and is used to diagnose sleep disorders.

In contrast, sleep trackers are typically wrist-worn devices that use algorithms to estimate sleep based on body movements and, in some cases, heart rate changes. While these devices provide insights into sleep habits and patterns, their accuracy has been questioned. Research has shown that sleep trackers are only accurate 78% of the time when identifying sleep versus wakefulness, and this accuracy drops to around 38% when estimating how long it takes to fall asleep.

Despite their limitations, sleep trackers have advantages such as relatively low cost, easy accessibility, and the ability to collect data over a long period without disrupting the wearer. These advantages make them promising tools for long-term, population-based sleep research. However, it is important for users to be aware of the potential for inaccurate data and unnecessary anxiety.

Frequently asked questions