Improving Sleep: Four-Day School Week Experiment

The four-day school week has become an increasingly popular model in the United States, with over 1,600 schools across 24 states adopting it. The model has varying results, with some schools reporting improved academic performance and increased student attendance, while others report a decrease in student achievement. The four-day school week model is exactly as it sounds – students attend school for four days a week instead of the traditional five, with the lost day compensated for by lengthening the hours of the remaining four days.

One of the primary motivations behind the four-day school week is financial. School districts that have implemented the model report savings in operating costs, with small savings making a difference by allowing districts to retain staff and invest in instructional support. The four-day week also helps with teacher recruitment and retention, with some districts reporting a significant increase in the number of teacher applications.

However, there are concerns about the impact of the four-day school week on student learning and health. Some studies show that students in four-day week districts perform better on standardized tests, while others show a decrease in student achievement due to longer days and loss of instructional time. Additionally, the shorter week may negatively impact sleep schedules, as students may try to catch up on sleep lost during the school week on the fifth day, leading to erratic sleep patterns associated with negative health consequences.

The four-day school week also has logistical implications, with the extra day off posing childcare challenges for working parents and potentially impacting after-school programs and transportation schedules. Despite these challenges, many administrators, teachers, parents, and students support the four-day school week, valuing the extra time it allows them to spend together.

A four-day school week may improve sleep for elementary school students

The four-day school week model has been adopted by several schools across the United States, with varying results. While some schools that have implemented the four-day week report improved academic performance, detractors argue that a longer school day might be counterproductive, leading to decreased concentration and productivity as students become tired.

Benefits of a four-day school week

A four-day school week can have several benefits for students, teachers, and school districts:

• Increased attendance: With a longer weekend, students may be less likely to miss school for appointments or family trips.
• Cost savings: The four-day model can save schools money by reducing expenses like transportation and utilities.
• Improved student performance: Some studies have shown that students perform better on standardized tests with the four-day week model.
• Retaining teachers: Shortening the school week has been found to improve teacher retention and job satisfaction.
• More rest for students: The extra day off can provide students with more opportunities for rest, family activities, and independent learning.

Potential drawbacks of a four-day school week

However, there are also some potential drawbacks and challenges to consider:

• Longer school days: Longer school days can be mentally and physically draining for students, leading to burnout.
• Childcare issues: Families, especially those with working parents, may struggle with finding childcare arrangements on the extra day off.
• Negative impact on low-income students: For families who rely on school meals, losing a day of school can have a negative impact.
• Potential for reduced student achievement: While some studies show improved test scores, others suggest that student achievement may decrease due to the longer days and loss of instructional time.
• Widening of the achievement gap: There are concerns about the potential widening of the achievement gap, especially for students from low-income families who may lack educational support at home on the extra day off.
• Logistical implications: The extra day off could impact after-school programs and disrupt transportation schedules.

Impact on sleep

A four-day school week can have varying effects on sleep patterns, depending on the age group. Elementary school students on the four-day schedule reported sleeping on average 89 minutes more across the school week than their five-day counterparts. However, for middle and high school students, there was no significant difference in sleep duration.

Older students may not benefit as much from a four-day week because it often comes with earlier start times, and research shows that teens sleep better when the school day starts later. A shorter school week could lead to more erratic sleep schedules, as students may try to catch up on sleep during the extra day off, which can have negative health consequences.

The four-day school week model has both potential benefits and challenges. Each school community should carefully consider its unique context, resources, and needs before making a decision. It is essential to involve all stakeholders—students, parents, teachers, and staff—in the decision-making process.

A four-day school week may not improve sleep for middle and high school students

One study found that elementary school students on a four-day schedule slept, on average, 89 minutes more across the school week than their five-day counterparts. However, for middle and high school students, there was no significant difference in sleep duration between the four-day and five-day schedules. This may be because four-day school weeks often come with earlier start times, and research shows that teenagers sleep better when the school day starts later.

The four-day school week model typically involves lengthening the school day to compensate for the lost day of instruction. As a result, students may experience longer school days that can be mentally and physically draining, leading to burnout and decreased concentration. This could potentially negate any positive effects of the extra day off on sleep for middle and high school students.

Furthermore, a shorter school week could lead to more erratic sleep schedules, as students may try to catch up on sleep during the three-day weekend. Variable sleep patterns have been associated with negative health consequences, including an increased risk of depression and obesity. Therefore, while the four-day school week may provide some benefits, such as improved teacher retention and cost savings, it may not significantly improve sleep for middle and high school students.

A four-day school week may lead to erratic sleep schedules

The four-day school week typically involves lengthening the school day to compensate for the lost day. As a result, students may experience longer school days that can be mentally and physically draining, leading to burnout and decreased concentration and productivity. This extended schedule may disrupt their sleep patterns, causing them to try to catch up on sleep during the three-day weekend.

Erratic sleep schedules can have negative health consequences. Variable sleep patterns have been associated with an increased risk of depression and obesity. Additionally, chronic sleep deprivation, which is common among teenagers due to the clash between early school start times and their natural sleep cycles, can lead to acute and long-term health risks, impair learning, and negatively impact mood and emotional regulation.

While a four-day school week may provide benefits such as cost savings and improved teacher retention, it is essential to carefully consider the potential impact on students' sleep schedules and overall well-being. Further research and careful consideration of all stakeholders' needs are necessary before implementing such a significant change to the school calendar.

A four-day school week may have educational and health risks for students

The four-day school week model has students attend school for four days instead of the traditional five, with the lost day compensated for by lengthening the hours of the remaining four days. This change can be mentally and physically draining for students, leading to burnout and decreased concentration and productivity. Longer school days may also widen the achievement gap, especially for low-income students who lack educational support at home.

Research suggests that the impact of a condensed schedule varies by student group and school type. For example, a study of six states found that students who went to class four days a week made less progress in reading than those who attended five days. However, the condensed schedule had little to no effect on rural students and even improved teacher retention and job satisfaction.

A trimmed school week can positively affect sleep, with elementary school students on a four-day schedule sleeping, on average, 89 minutes more than their five-day counterparts. However, older students did not see the same benefit, likely due to earlier start times. A shorter school week could lead to more erratic sleep schedules, as students may try to catch up on sleep lost during the week on the fifth day. Variable sleep patterns have been associated with negative health consequences, including an increased risk of depression and obesity.

A four-day school week may have benefits for students and school districts

A four-day school week has been adopted by several schools across the United States, with varying results. While some schools have reported improved academic performance, others have noted a decrease in student achievement. Here are some of the potential benefits of a four-day school week for students and school districts:

Benefits for Students

• Improved sleep: Elementary school students on a four-day schedule reported sleeping, on average, 89 minutes more across the week than their five-day counterparts. This extra day off can provide students with more opportunities for rest, which can positively impact their overall health and well-being.
• Increased attendance: With a longer weekend, students may be less likely to miss school for appointments or family trips, reducing absenteeism.
• Improved academic performance: A shorter week can reduce student fatigue and increase engagement during school hours, potentially leading to better academic outcomes.
• More time for rest and extracurricular activities: The extra day off can provide students with additional time for rest, family activities, and independent learning, promoting a healthier balance between academic and personal pursuits.
• Reduced bullying and fighting: Research suggests that a four-day school week may lead to a decrease in bullying and fighting incidents among students, creating a safer and more positive school environment.

Benefits for School Districts

• Cost savings: The four-day model can reduce expenses for transportation, utilities, and substitute teachers, resulting in cost savings for school districts.
• Improved teacher retention and job satisfaction: The extra day off can improve teacher retention and job satisfaction by providing teachers with more time for lesson planning, professional development, and personal rest. This can lead to a more stable and satisfied teaching staff.
• Enhanced staff morale: A four-day school week has been found to boost staff morale, creating a more positive work environment and potentially improving overall productivity.
• Attracting and retaining teachers: The four-day week can be an attractive incentive for teachers, making it easier for school districts to recruit and retain qualified educators, especially in areas facing teacher shortages.

Frequently asked questions