Living Without Rem Sleep: Is It Possible?

Sleep is divided into four stages, the fourth of which is REM sleep, characterised by relaxed muscles, quick eye movement, irregular breathing, elevated heart rate, and increased brain activity. While it is difficult to attribute side effects of sleep deprivation to a specific aspect of sleep, a lack of REM sleep can lead to fatigue, irritability, changes in mood and memory, and issues with cognition and problem-solving. REM sleep is thought to be important for memory consolidation, emotional processing, brain development, and dreaming.

Some people seem to be able to survive without REM sleep. For example, a man with a brain injury lost REM sleep but went on to become a lawyer and the puzzle editor for a newspaper. Similarly, a patient with Morvan syndrome experienced agrypnia (complete loss of sleep) for four months but did not experience any cognitive decline. However, studies have shown that reduced REM sleep is linked to a higher risk of death, especially from cardiovascular disease.

So, while it is technically possible to live without REM sleep, it may not be advisable.

REM sleep and memory consolidation

REM sleep is a stage of sleep characterised by rapid eye movement, muscle paralysis, irregular breathing, increased heart rate, and brain activity. It is thought to be important for memory consolidation, emotional processing, brain development, and dreaming.

REM sleep was first discovered in the 1950s, when scientists studying sleeping infants noticed that there were distinct periods when their eyes moved rapidly from side to side. These rapid eye movements, or REMs, earned REM sleep its name.

REM sleep is one of the four stages of sleep, the others being light sleep, light sleep, and deep sleep. During REM sleep, the brain is highly active, and the body experiences a temporary loss of muscle tone.

REM sleep is thought to be important for memory consolidation, emotional processing, brain development, and dreaming. However, the exact function of REM sleep is still not fully understood.

REM sleep and brain development

REM sleep is vital for brain development, especially in newborns and young children. During this stage of sleep, the brain is highly active, and dreaming occurs. REM sleep is also characterised by relaxed muscles, quick eye movement, irregular breathing, elevated heart rate, and brain activity similar to that of a wakeful state.

REM sleep is important for the consolidation of memory and emotions, and it is believed to be essential for the development of the central nervous system. Research has shown that REM sleep selectively prunes and maintains new synapses in development and learning. This process is critical for normal neuronal circuit development and behavioural improvement after learning.

REM sleep is also thought to be important for the development of procedural memory, which is the type of memory used when learning a new skill. It may also help with problem-solving, as unique connections within the brain are made during this stage of sleep.

Newborns spend most of their sleep time in REM sleep, and this gradually decreases as they get older. By adulthood, the average amount of REM sleep needed is around two hours per night.

REM sleep and emotional processing

REM sleep is a stage of sleep characterised by relaxed muscles, quick eye movement, irregular breathing, elevated heart rate, and increased brain activity. It is thought to play a role in memory consolidation, emotional processing, brain development, and dreaming.

REM sleep is important for our general well-being, considering that non-REM sleep, REM sleep and REM dreaming play a modulating function on our emotions experienced during the day. During REM sleep, the diminished functioning of the executive function circuit combined with an enhanced adaptive activity of limbic networks which support emotional processes helps us to regulate the emotional events that we encounter during daily life.

REM sleep deprivation is followed by the rebound of REM sleep and slow wave sleep in the following nights. This effect suggests that a certain amount of REM sleep and slow wave sleep is crucial for sleep. Clinical evidence suggests that sleep has a role in regulating our emotional brain-state since sleep impairment corresponds to affective dysfunction.

REM sleep deprivation affects emotional reactivity and social function. Without enough healthy sleep, negative emotional reactivity seems to be significantly enhanced and positive reactions to positive events are often subdued.

A lack of REM sleep leads to physical symptoms, too, consistent with sleep deprivation in general. It can affect cardiovascular health and increase the risk of type 2 diabetes. It may also contribute to cancer, stroke, and neurodegenerative diseases like Alzheimer's.

REM sleep and physical health

Research suggests that REM sleep plays a crucial role in maintaining physical health and well-being. While the exact purpose of REM sleep remains unknown, it is associated with several important functions, including memory consolidation, emotional processing, brain development, and dreaming. Disruptions in REM sleep can have significant impacts on overall health and contribute to various physical health issues.

Impact on Memory and Cognition

REM sleep is believed to be essential for memory consolidation, particularly procedural memory. This is the type of memory involved in learning new skills, such as riding a bike. Studies have shown that a lack of REM sleep can lead to problems with memory and cognitive tasks during the day. Individuals may experience fatigue, irritability, mood changes, and issues with problem-solving abilities. Additionally, REM sleep may also play a role in enhancing our ability to solve problems by facilitating unique connections within the brain.

Cardiovascular Health and Disease Risk

Disruptions in REM sleep have been linked to an increased risk of cardiovascular disease and other physical health issues. One study found that men who experienced a 5% loss of REM sleep had a 13% higher risk of cardiovascular-related death over a 12-year period. This association was also observed in a separate study on a younger and more diverse group of participants, suggesting a potential causal link.

Additionally, chronic sleep deprivation has been associated with various health conditions, including obesity, metabolic disorders, and an increased risk of sleep apnea, which can further impact cardiovascular health.

Immune System and Overall Health

REM sleep is thought to play a role in regulating the immune system. Sleep deprivation can compromise the immune system, making individuals more susceptible to illnesses and infections. Additionally, chronic sleep loss has been linked to an increased risk of chronic diseases such as diabetes, depression, high blood pressure, cancer, and obesity.

It is important to note that the effects of REM sleep deprivation may be challenging to isolate, as overall sleep disruption can have comprehensive impacts on physical health. However, the available research suggests that adequate REM sleep is vital for maintaining optimal physical health and reducing the risk of various health conditions.

REM sleep and mental health

REM sleep is vital for mental health and well-being. A lack of REM sleep can lead to fatigue, irritability, and changes in mood and memory. It can also cause problems with cognition and problem-solving abilities. Research suggests that REM sleep plays a crucial role in daytime function and wakefulness, learning, and memory consolidation.

REM sleep is closely linked to emotional processing and mental health. It is associated with the activation of brain regions involved in mood regulation, such as the amygdala and dorsolateral prefrontal cortex. Depressed and anxious individuals often experience negative dreams and nightmares during REM sleep, which may contribute to cognitive distortions associated with these disorders. Studies have found that REM sleep deprivation can temporarily alleviate symptoms of depression and anxiety in some individuals, highlighting the complex relationship between REM sleep and mental health.

Additionally, REM sleep behaviour disorder (RBD) is a parasomnia where individuals physically act out their dreams, potentially causing harm to themselves or their bed partners. RBD is often associated with underlying neurodegenerative disorders, such as Parkinson's disease, and can serve as an early warning sign for these conditions.

Frequently asked questions