Fitbit's Accuracy In Tracking Rem Sleep Stages

Sleep is an essential component of health, and the best way to know if you're getting enough is to track it. Fitbit devices can help you do this. They estimate sleep stages by using a combination of movement and heart-rate patterns. When you haven't moved for about an hour, your Fitbit tracker assumes you're asleep. It also takes into account the length of time you're moving around, which could indicate sleep behaviour such as rolling over. While you sleep, your Fitbit device tracks the beat-to-beat changes in your heart rate, known as heart rate variability (HRV), which fluctuate as you transition between light sleep, deep sleep, and REM sleep stages. However, some sources claim that Fitbit cannot accurately tell you about your REM or deep sleep stages and that more sophisticated equipment is needed for this.

Fitbit's accuracy in determining sleep stages

Fitbit devices with heart-rate tracking can estimate sleep stages by using movement and heart-rate patterns. When a user hasn't moved for about an hour, the tracker assumes they are asleep. Additional data, such as the length of time of movements that are indicative of sleep behaviour (like rolling over), can also help confirm that the user is asleep.

While the user sleeps, the device tracks beat-to-beat changes in their heart rate, known as heart rate variability (HRV). These numbers fluctuate as the user transitions between light sleep, deep sleep, and REM sleep stages. When the user syncs their device in the morning, Fitbit uses movement and heart rate patterns to estimate sleep cycles from the previous night.

Fitbit's sleep researchers and the National Sleep Foundation describe the following sleep stages:

• Light sleep: This is the entry point into sleep each night as the body unwinds and slows down. This stage typically begins within minutes of falling asleep. During the early part of light sleep, the user may drift between being awake and asleep, remaining somewhat alert and easily awoken. Their breathing and heart rate usually decrease slightly during this stage. Light sleep promotes mental and physical recovery.
• Deep sleep: This typically occurs in the first few hours of sleep. When the user wakes up feeling refreshed in the morning, they likely experienced solid periods of deep sleep the night before. During deep sleep, the user becomes harder to awaken since their body becomes less responsive to outside stimuli. Their breathing slows down, their muscles relax, and their heart rate usually becomes more regular. Deep sleep promotes physical recovery and supports aspects of memory and learning, as well as the immune system.
• REM sleep: This stage is associated with vivid dreams and typically occurs later in the night. During this final stage of sleep, the user's brain becomes more active, and their eyes move quickly in different directions. Their heart rate increases, and their breathing becomes more irregular. REM sleep has been shown to play an important role in mood regulation, learning, and memory as the brain processes and consolidates information from the previous day so that it can be stored in long-term memory.

According to a 2017 paper published by Fitbit scientists, the watch's sensors can classify sleep stages with 69% accuracy in any given 30-second time window. This means that Fitbit's sleep staging is only correct in these 30-second blocks slightly more than two-thirds of the time. There is no systematic bias to how much light sleep, deep sleep, or sleeplessness Fitbit estimates. In other words, Fitbit does not over or underestimate the duration of these stages. Therefore, if the app is used for many nights, the user will eventually get a good sense of how often they tend to be awake, lightly asleep, or deeply asleep on a typical night.

Some studies have concluded that Fitbit devices are "pretty accurate" with sleep tracking, and one study identified the Fitbit Alta as the most accurate sleep tracker, close to sophisticated sleep sensors. However, another source states that Fitbit cannot accurately tell the user about their REM or deep sleep stages. For this, more sophisticated equipment is needed, such as an eye tracker or brain wave monitor.

Limitations of Fitbit's sleep tracking

While Fitbit's sleep tracking technology is innovative, there are some limitations to its accuracy and functionality. Firstly, it is important to note that Fitbit devices are not designed to diagnose or treat sleep disorders. They are intended for general wellness and fitness purposes only. If a user suspects they have a sleep disorder, they should consult a medical professional.

Fitbit's sleep tracking relies primarily on movement and heart rate patterns. This means that the accuracy of sleep tracking can be affected by factors such as the user's sleeping position, the fit of the device, and the user's level of movement during sleep. For example, if a user sleeps in a position that prevents the device from getting a consistent heart rate reading or wears it too loosely, the accuracy of the sleep data may be compromised. Additionally, users who move more during their sleep may find that the readings are less accurate.

Another limitation of Fitbit's sleep tracking is that it cannot accurately determine REM or deep sleep stages. While it estimates sleep stages based on movement and heart rate variability, more sophisticated equipment, such as eye trackers and brain wave monitors, are needed for precise REM and deep sleep measurements. The SpO2 sensor on some Fitbit devices, which has the potential to provide valuable information about sleep apnea, is currently not utilised by the Fitbit app and awaits government approval for implementation.

Furthermore, Fitbit's sleep tracking may not be suitable for all users, especially those with irregular sleep patterns or those who take frequent naps. The device assumes the user is asleep when there is no movement for about an hour, which may not always be the case for individuals with sleep disturbances or those who take short naps. Additionally, the sleep tracking feature requires a minimum of 3 hours of sleep data to estimate sleep stages, so it may not be useful for individuals who take shorter naps.

Lastly, Fitbit's sleep tracking algorithm may not account for individual variations in sleep patterns. While it provides typical ranges for different sleep stages based on age and gender, it may not capture the unique sleep patterns of each user. Therefore, it is important for users to consider their own sleep habits and patterns when interpreting the data provided by Fitbit.

How Fitbit's sleep tracking works

Fitbit's sleep tracking features use advanced signal processing and machine learning algorithms to track total time slept, as well as identify trends in restlessness and the amount of time people are awake during a sleep period. The accelerometer in the Fitbit Versa infers when you're sleeping and what stage of sleep you're in by measuring bodily accelerations of the wrist. It also uses optical photoplethysmography (PPG) to measure blood flow based on how green light from an LED on the back of the watch is reflected by the body.

Fitbit estimates sleep stages by using your movement and heart-rate patterns. When you don't move for about an hour, your tracker or watch assumes you're asleep. Additional data such as the length of time when your movements indicate sleep behaviour (like rolling over) help confirm your sleep status. While you sleep, your device tracks the beat-to-beat changes in your heart rate, known as heart rate variability (HRV), which fluctuate as you transition between light sleep, deep sleep, and REM sleep stages. When you sync your device in the morning, it uses your movement and heart rate patterns to estimate your sleep cycles from the previous night.

Fitbit's Sleep Stages feature uses accelerometer data, heart rate variability (the changes in time between beats) and algorithms to more accurately estimate how long you spend in light, deep and REM sleep stages (as well as time awake) each night. The Sleep Stages feature is based on accelerometer data from several hundred nights of heart rate and movement data from volunteer sleepers, which was simultaneously characterised with gold-standard lab equipment.

Fitbit's sleep tracking features

Here's how it works: when you haven't moved for about an hour, your Fitbit tracker or smartwatch assumes you're asleep. It also takes into account additional data, such as the length of time you spend rolling over or exhibiting other sleep behaviours. While you sleep, the device tracks the beat-to-beat changes in your heart rate, known as heart rate variability (HRV). These numbers fluctuate as you transition between light sleep, deep sleep, and REM sleep stages. In the morning, when you sync your device, Fitbit uses these movement and heart rate patterns to estimate your sleep cycles from the previous night.

Fitbit's Sleep Stages feature uses accelerometer data, heart rate variability, and algorithms to estimate how long you spend in each sleep stage: light, deep, and REM sleep, as well as the time spent awake. The accelerometer measures bodily accelerations of the wrist, while heart rate variability refers to the changes in time between heartbeats.

In addition to tracking your sleep stages, Fitbit provides a Sleep Score to help you understand your sleep quality. This score is based on heart rate, the time spent awake or restless, and sleep stages. Most Fitbit users receive a score between 72 and 83. The score is further broken down into three components: sleep duration, sleep quality, and restoration.

Fitbit also offers Premium membership, which includes additional sleep tracking features. With Premium, you can access a deeper Sleep Score breakdown, guided sleep programs, cross-correlated insights based on your sleep and activity data, and sleep audio relaxation and mindfulness tools.

Improving your Fitbit Sleep Score

Fitbit's Sleep Score is a feature that combines multiple factors to give you an easy way to see how well you're sleeping. It looks at your sleeping heart rate data, time asleep, and restlessness throughout the night. Here are some tips to help you improve your Fitbit Sleep Score:

• Exercise during the day: Try to exercise earlier in the day or at least 3 to 4 hours before you sleep. This will help tire your body out and improve your sleep quality.
• Maintain a consistent sleep schedule: Go to bed and wake up at the same time every day. This will help improve the length and quality of your sleep. You can use Fitbit's sleep schedule feature to set bedtime reminders and wake-up targets.
• Meet the recommended weekly activity: Aim for at least 150 active minutes per week. This will help improve your overall health and energy levels, which can positively impact your sleep.
• Create a relaxing bedtime routine: Develop a calming pre-sleep routine to help you unwind and relax before bed. This could include activities such as reading, listening to soothing music, or practising meditation or deep breathing exercises.
• Reduce blue light exposure: Power down your devices at least an hour before bed to minimise blue light exposure, which can interfere with your sleep.
• Limit caffeine, alcohol, and stress: These factors can impact your sleeping heart rate and make it harder to fall and stay asleep. Try to limit your intake of caffeine and alcohol, especially close to bedtime. Additionally, find healthy ways to manage stress, such as through exercise, meditation, or relaxation techniques.
• Optimise your sleep environment: Ensure your bedroom is cool, dark, and quiet. Consider using blackout curtains, earplugs, or a white noise machine to create a comfortable sleep environment.
• Address sleep disorders: If you suspect you may have a sleep disorder, such as sleep apnea, consult a doctor. They can provide guidance and recommend further steps, such as a sleep study, to improve your sleep quality.
• Utilise Fitbit Premium: Fitbit Premium offers more in-depth analysis and personalised guidance. It provides a detailed breakdown of your Sleep Score, highlighting areas where your sleep needs improvement. It also offers guided sleep programs and personalised sleep insights to help you make specific changes for better rest.

Frequently asked questions