Sleep Tracking Apps: Safe Or Privacy Nightmare?

Sleep tracking apps are a popular way to monitor sleep patterns and quality. They can be used as a self-management tool to improve sleep quality and track sleep disorders. However, the accuracy of these apps has been questioned, and they may not be suitable for everyone. Sleep tracking apps use varying algorithms and technologies, such as accelerometers, sonar, and optical heart-rate monitoring, to collect sleep data. While they can provide insights into sleep habits, they don't directly measure sleep and are not a replacement for medical sleep studies or professional advice. The safety and effectiveness of sleep tracking apps are ongoing areas of research and improvement.

Sleep trackers can be inaccurate

While commercial sleep trackers show promise in tracking when a person is awake or asleep, they need to be more sensitive to accurately detect sleep stages. Commercial trackers may misreport the time spent in each cycle and the total number of cycles each night, which are important aspects of sleep health. The primary limiting factor for commercial wearables is the lack of studies that corroborate their accuracy compared to actigraphy or polysomnography (PSG). PSG is used by doctors to diagnose sleep disorders, but the tests are expensive, the equipment is cumbersome, and the data requires an in-lab evaluation by a specialist.

Sleep trackers may give the impression that they can diagnose a medical condition when they don't have the data (or FDA approval) to back up those claims. Users should take the numbers with a grain of salt and consult a health practitioner if they have concerns about their sleep quality. Sleep trackers can be useful for helping users recognize patterns in their sleep habits and can provide insights into their sleep routines. For example, if a user's sleep time changed abruptly, they can look for changes in stress, environment, or daytime habits that might have sparked that change.

Some sleep trackers have been found to be more accurate than others. For instance, the Ultrahuman Ring Air has been praised for its accuracy and the valuable advice in the accompanying app. The ring has a medical-grade temperature sensor, a PPG (photoplethysmography) sensor, and a motion-sensing IMU (inertial measurement unit). The Apple Watch Series 8 and 9 have also been found to do a decent job of reporting sleep stages, although Apple's charts are hard to read and lack depth in statistical analysis.

Sleep trackers can be useful for spotting trends

Sleep trackers come in various forms, including wearable devices that you can strap to your wrist, or those that clip to your pillow or sit on your bedside table. They collect data on sleep duration and quality, tracking the time you're inactive and detecting interruptions during the night. Some trackers also allow you to input lifestyle factors such as caffeine intake, meal times, and stress levels, which can impact your sleep.

The data provided by sleep trackers is often presented in user-friendly graphs or reports, making it easier to identify trends and patterns. For instance, you might discover that you feel more energised when you sleep from 11 pm to 7 am compared to sleeping from 10 pm to 6 am. You might also find that your bedroom temperature or your exercise habits influence the quality of your sleep.

Additionally, sleep trackers can be a good option for healthy individuals who want to gain insights into their sleep routines. They can help you set goals and make changes to improve your sleep. However, it's important to remember that sleep trackers are not a substitute for medical advice or diagnosis. If you have concerns about your sleep quality, it's recommended to consult a healthcare professional.

While sleep trackers offer trend-spotting capabilities, it's worth noting that their accuracy can vary. Different trackers using similar technology may produce varying sleep reports. The precision of personal sleep-tracking devices is still a work in progress, and they may not be suitable for individuals in professions where sleep analysis is crucial, such as elite athletes or pilots.

Sleep trackers can't diagnose medical conditions

Sleep trackers can be a great way to gain insight into your sleep routine and habits. They can help you recognise patterns in your sleep habits and nudge you towards adopting healthier sleep behaviours. However, it is important to remember that sleep trackers are not medical devices and cannot diagnose medical conditions.

Sleep trackers are not designed to diagnose sleep disorders or other health problems. They do not measure sleep directly but often use inactivity as a surrogate for estimating sleep. While they can provide some useful information, they are not as accurate as the medical monitoring you would receive in a sleep clinic. The data from sleep trackers should be taken with a grain of salt.

Sleep trackers often rely on measuring inactivity to estimate sleep. They may track the time you are inactive and record when you fall asleep and wake up. Some trackers can also detect interrupted sleep, letting you know when you toss and turn or wake up during the night. They may also track your sleep phases and time your alarm to go off during a period of lighter sleep. However, these are still estimates, and the exact data about your sleep habits can only be obtained through a medical sleep study that monitors brain waves and other physiological parameters.

Additionally, sleep trackers may give the impression that they can diagnose a medical condition when they lack the data and regulatory approval to support such claims. For example, while a sleep tracker may help identify potential symptoms of sleep apnea, it is not a tool used by doctors to diagnose this condition. Sleep trackers are considered lifestyle or entertainment devices and are not currently regulated by the Food and Drug Administration (FDA).

While sleep trackers can provide some useful insights, they should not be solely relied upon for diagnosing or treating sleep issues. If you have concerns about your sleep quality or suspect a sleep disorder, it is advisable to consult a healthcare professional. They are trained to screen for and diagnose sleep problems using in-office tests, laboratory sleep studies, and medical histories.

Sleep trackers can help with sleep disorders

Sleep trackers can be a valuable tool for people with sleep disorders. They can provide insights into sleep patterns and help users identify trends in their sleep habits. For example, a sleep tracker can help a person understand if their bedroom temperature affects their sleep or if caffeine consumption after lunchtime disrupts their sleep.

Sleep trackers can also help detect underlying sleep-related breathing disorders by continuously monitoring blood oxygen levels. For instance, the SLEEPON Go2Sleep 3 Tracker is a ring that syncs with a user's phone and can identify dips in blood oxygen levels. It also monitors blood glucose levels and heart rate and uses an algorithm to analyze sleep stages and overall sleep quality. The Oura Ring 4 is another wearable sleep tracker that monitors a wide range of metrics to evaluate sleep and daytime activities.

Sleep trackers can also help users identify the optimal time to go to bed and wake up. For example, a person may feel sluggish sleeping from 10 pm to 6 am but feel more energetic when shifting their sleep to 11 pm to 7 am. This information can be useful for people with sleep disorders to optimize their sleep schedules.

Additionally, some sleep trackers have features that assist healthcare professionals in monitoring and screening their patients for conditions such as habitual snoring and obstructive sleep apnea. While sleep trackers cannot replace medical monitoring in a sleep clinic, they can provide valuable insights and help users reflect on their sleep habits.

It is important to note that sleep trackers have limitations and potential drawbacks. They do not directly measure sleep and may not always be accurate. Some studies have found that popular sleep trackers can overestimate sleep duration by up to an hour. Therefore, it is recommended to take the numbers provided by sleep trackers with a grain of salt and consult a healthcare professional if there are concerns about sleep quality.

Sleep trackers can be used with other devices

Smartphone applications for sleep tracking are also available and can be used in conjunction with wearable devices. These apps can provide additional insights and analysis of sleep data. They often employ built-in mobile sensors, such as microphones and light detectors, to obtain sleep data. Some apps offer smart alarms, sleep aids, sound recording during sleep, and analysis of sleep patterns. It is important to note that while these apps can be useful, they may not provide exact data or medical advice.

In addition to smartphones, sleep trackers can also be used with other devices such as GPS devices or fitness trackers. For example, Garmin's fitness trackers, such as the Epix Pro, offer Advanced Sleep Monitoring, tracking sleep stages, blood oxygen saturation, respiration, and restlessness. The Connect app, used with Garmin devices, allows users to set Sleep and Wake windows for more accurate sleep tracking.

When choosing a sleep tracker, it is important to consider how it fits into your digital ecosystem and how easy it is to use. Additionally, the comfort of wearable devices is an important factor, as you will be wearing them during sleep. It is worth trying out different options to find the best fit for your needs and preferences.

Frequently asked questions