Earl, Just Lay Down And Sleep

Why don't you lay down and sleep, Earl? is a lyric from the song Goodbye Earl by the Dixie Chicks. The song, written by Dennis Linde, tells the story of two high school friends, Mary Anne and Wanda, whose lives take different paths after graduation. While Mary Anne leaves town, Wanda stays and falls in love with a man named Earl, who soon becomes abusive. The lyric Why don't you lay down and sleep, Earl? is part of the song's darkly humorous depiction of how the two women ultimately get their revenge on Earl by poisoning him with black-eyed peas and wrapping his body in a tarp. The song sparked controversy upon its release, with some radio stations refusing to play it due to its violent themes, while others used it as an opportunity to raise awareness about domestic abuse.

The song's narrative

"Goodbye Earl" is a country music song written by Dennis Linde and recorded by the Dixie Chicks for their fifth studio album, Fly. The song tells the story of two high school best friends, Mary Anne and Wanda, whose lives take drastically different paths after graduation. While Mary Anne leaves town in search of new opportunities, Wanda stays and falls in love with a man named Earl.

The song describes how, just two weeks into their marriage, Wanda starts facing abuse from Earl. She tries to conceal the bruises with dark glasses, long-sleeved blouses, and makeup, but eventually finds the courage to file for divorce and obtains a restraining order against him. Unfortunately, Earl disregards the restraining order and violently assaults Wanda, putting her in intensive care.

Mary Anne rushes back to town and joins Wanda in plotting their revenge against Earl. They decide to kill him by poisoning his black-eyed peas and disposing of his body in a nearby lake. The lyrics, "Those black-eyed peas, they tasted alright to me, Earl/You're feeling weak? Why don't you lay down and sleep, Earl/Ain't it dark wrapped up in that tarp, Earl?" hint at the deadly plan.

The women carry out their plan, and when the cops come looking for Earl, they search the house but find nothing. The weeks turn into seasons, and Earl is deemed a missing person, but "nobody missed him at all." Mary Anne and Wanda, free from their abuser, buy some land and open a roadside stand, selling Tennessee ham and strawberry jam. They live happily ever after, without losing any sleep over Earl's disappearance.

The character Earl

Earl is the main antagonist of the song "Goodbye Earl" by the Dixie Chicks. He is the abusive husband of Wanda, one of the two main characters in the song. The other main character, Mary Ann, is Wanda's best friend.

Earl is described as "a detestable" character, and his abuse of Wanda begins almost immediately after their marriage. Wanda attempts to hide the abuse by "put [ting] on dark glasses or long-sleeved blouses / Or make-up to cover a bruise." Eventually, she finds the courage to file for divorce and obtains a restraining order against Earl. However, he disregards the restraining order and puts Wanda in intensive care.

In response, Mary Ann flies back to town to support her friend. Together, they devise a plan for revenge. They decide to kill Earl by poisoning him with black-eyed peas and wrapping his body in a tarp. The song's lyrics, "You're feeling weak? / Why don't you lay down and sleep, Earl? / Ain't it dark wrapped up in that tarp, Earl?" are sung from the perspective of the two women, taunting Earl as they carry out their plan.

After killing Earl, the women dispose of his body by tossing it into a nearby lake. The town notices Earl's disappearance, but no one seems to care, as he was an awful person. The song concludes with Mary Ann and Wanda living happily ever after, selling Tennessee ham and strawberry jam at a roadside stand.

The character of Earl is a fictional creation of songwriter Dennis Linde, who had previously featured a character by the same name in Sammy Kershaw's song "Queen of My Double-Wide Trailer." Linde intended to kill off the character in "Goodbye Earl," providing a deserved send-off for the detestable Earl.

The Dixie Chicks' response to the song

> I think initially when we heard it, we just thought it was so funny. We’re not saying kill your husband if he touches you. It was more [like], ‘This is a bad character, and these girls are going to do something really bad to him, but don’t take it too seriously.

The song's lyrics tell the story of two women, Mary Anne and Wanda, who kill Wanda's abusive husband, Earl, by poisoning him with black-eyed peas. The Dixie Chicks included a disclaimer with the song, stating: "The Dixie Chicks do not advocate premeditated murder, but do love getting even."

The music video for "Goodbye Earl" was intended to be funny, with the Chicks describing the song as their "ode to O.J. Simpson". The video features a cast of well-known actors, including Dennis Franz as Earl, Lauren Holly as Mary Anne, and Jane Krakowski as Wanda. The video won the Academy of Country Music and Country Music Association award for Video of the Year.

Despite the light-hearted and humorous way in which the song and video were presented, some radio stations refused to play "Goodbye Earl" due to its controversial themes of domestic violence and murder. The Dixie Chicks' lead vocalist, Natalie Maines, addressed the song's detractors, stating that it was not intended to be taken seriously and that it was simply a way to address a difficult topic in a light-hearted manner.

The song's impact on pop culture

"Goodbye Earl", written by Dennis Linde, is a country music song that gained fame when it was recorded by the Dixie Chicks. The song has had a significant impact on pop culture, resonating with many people and inspiring numerous parodies and references in TV shows and films.

The song's story of two women, Mary Anne and Wanda, killing Wanda's abusive husband, Earl, stirred controversy due to its violent theme. Despite this, or perhaps because of it, the song struck a chord with many listeners, who saw it as a feminist anthem. The song's catchy tune and stark storyline made it stand out, and it inspired parodies across different music genres.

The impact of "Goodbye Earl" can be seen in its influence on other songs about wronged women seeking retribution. For example, Miranda Lambert's "Gunpowder & Lead" and Carrie Underwood's "Church Bells" both deal with similar themes of female empowerment and taking a stand against abuse. "Goodbye Earl" helped pave the way for these and other songs that address issues of domestic violence and female agency.

The song has also been referenced and featured in popular culture, including an episode of "The Office" and the film "Tammy." The song's lyrics and storyline have become ingrained in pop culture, with phrases like "Why don't you lay down and sleep, Earl?" becoming recognisable even to those who may not have heard the original song.

Overall, "Goodbye Earl" by the Dixie Chicks has had a lasting impact on pop culture, influencing music, film, and television. It has sparked conversations about domestic violence, female empowerment, and the role of music in addressing social issues. The song's catchy tune and controversial storyline ensured its place in the cultural zeitgeist, with its impact still being felt today.

The song's controversial themes

"Goodbye Earl", a song by the Dixie Chicks, is a revenge anthem with darkly humorous lyrics and a controversial message. The song's narrative revolves around two high school friends, Mary Anne and Wanda, whose lives take divergent paths after graduation. While Mary Anne leaves town in pursuit of new horizons, Wanda remains and falls in love with a man named Earl, who soon becomes her abusive husband. Despite Wanda's attempts to escape the abuse, including filing for divorce and obtaining a restraining order, Earl continues to torment her, even putting her in intensive care.

In response, Mary Anne returns to town, and the two friends conspire to murder Earl. They poison him with black-eyed peas, wrap his body in a tarp, and dispose of it in a nearby lake. The lyrics, "You're feeling weak? Why don't you lay down and sleep, Earl? Ain't it dark wrapped up in that tarp, Earl?", allude to the sinister fate they devise for him. The song continues with a description of the aftermath, where the women get away with their crime, start a new life, and "don't lose any sleep at night".

The song's music video further added to the controversy. Directed by Evan Bernard, it featured a cast of well-known actors, including Dennis Franz as Earl, and portrayed the story with comedic relief and exaggerated performances. While some listeners understood the song's message as a form of wish fulfilment or a way to raise awareness about domestic abuse, others found its lighthearted treatment of murder and abuse distasteful and insensitive.

Despite the controversy, "Goodbye Earl" resonated with many listeners and became a successful and influential song, inspiring similar songs about women seeking retribution in the face of abuse.

Frequently asked questions