Anesthesia And Rem Sleep: Are They Similar States?

Sleep and anesthesia are two distinct states with many similarities. Both sleep and anesthesia are characterised by unconsciousness, but the latter is induced by medication and is reversible. Sleep, on the other hand, is endogenously generated and is dependent on homeostatic drive and circadian rhythms.

Sleep is divided into two distinct states: rapid eye movement (REM) sleep and non-rapid eye movement (NREM) sleep, with the brain and body slowing down during the latter. During REM sleep, the brain is very much like an awake state. Throughout the night, we cycle between the two states every 90 minutes or so.

Anesthesia, on the other hand, is marked by hypnosis, analgesia, akinesia, and anxiolysis. It displays a more widespread disruption of brain connectivity than sleep, impairing information integration and processing. The immobility component of anesthesia is produced by active inhibition of neural circuits in the brainstem and spinal cord, resulting in the suppression of reflex withdrawal from noxious stimuli.

While sleep is associated with amnesia, it plays a key role in memory consolidation and cognitive development. Anesthesia, on the other hand, has been shown to cause neurotoxicity in the extremes of age.

Furthermore, sleep offset occurs rapidly, and there is an intrinsic resistance to reinitiating sleep immediately after waking. In contrast, resumption of wakefulness from general anesthesia can take hours, and the process of anesthetic induction and emergence are not reciprocal.

While some similarities exist between sleep and anesthesia, there are fundamental physiological differences that set them apart.

Sleep and anesthesia have different effects on the brain

Sleep Onset

Sleep is actively generated in the brain and is dependent on homeostatic drive and circadian rhythms. The ease of sleep onset is subject to environmental factors such as temperature, noise, light, and chemical stimulants. Once non-rapid eye movement (NREM) sleep is established, there is regular cycling between this state and rapid eye movement (REM) sleep at approximately 90-minute intervals.

Anesthesia, on the other hand, is a pharmacologically induced state. The stages of anesthesia do not show the fluctuation and cycling seen in sleep. Instead, there is cycling of brain states during maintenance at steady-state concentrations, with varying electroencephalogram (EEG) readings.

Sleep and Anesthesia Maintenance Period

During sleep, there is a transition from slow-wave sleep to REM sleep, which corresponds to a switch from delta waves to low-voltage, high-frequency EEG activity. REM sleep is often described as "paradoxical sleep" due to similarities between its EEG and that of wakefulness. However, there are differences, including the decoupling of thalamocortical activity during REM sleep, which remains coupled during wakefulness.

In contrast, a common EEG pattern during deep anesthesia is burst suppression, marked by alternating periods of high voltage activity in the brain and periods of no brain activity. Burst suppression is associated with a depletion of extracellular calcium levels, which interferes with calcium-dependent neurotransmitter release in synaptic transmission.

Reflex Suppression and Atonia

The immobility component of anesthesia is produced by active inhibition of neural circuits in the brainstem and spinal cord, leading to suppression of reflex withdrawal from noxious stimuli. Spinal cord reflex loops are conserved during natural sleep, and postural control is diminished in anesthesia, unlike in sleep, where species-specific body postures are held during NREM sleep. Additionally, protective reflexes such as the cough and gag reflexes are lost during anesthesia, requiring artificial maintenance of airway patency.

Autonomic Nervous System Response

The reflex activation of the sympathetic nervous system in response to noxious stimuli is suppressed during anesthesia, which diminishes responses that would otherwise reverse natural sleep.

Role in Cognitive Development

While sleep is characterized by amnesia, it plays a key role in memory consolidation and cognitive development. In contrast, anesthesia exhibits neurotoxicity at the extremes of age, although the etiology is poorly understood. In neonates, typical anesthetic agents interfere with the neurogenesis process, and in the elderly, anesthesia is associated with postoperative cognitive dysfunction and acceleration of endogenous neurodegenerative processes.

Sleep and Anesthesia Emergence

Sleep offset occurs rapidly, within minutes, and there is intrinsic resistance to reinitiating sleep immediately after waking. Conversely, resumption of wakefulness from anesthesia can take hours, and it is not simply a reversal of the induction process. The hypnotic component of anesthesia renders a patient unrousable even by vigorous stimuli. Under anesthesia, enhanced GABA-mediated inhibition and depressed glutamate-mediated excitation on the cortex prevent the cortical depolarization required for the transition into wakefulness.

Other Differences

• Anesthesia is a drug-induced coma that includes analgesia (lack of pain perception), amnesia (lack of memory formation), and akinesia (inability to move), in addition to unconsciousness.
• Sleep is a natural physiologic process that needs to take place for mental and physical health, while anesthesia is not.
• Sleep moves between slow waves of NREM sleep and fast waves of REM sleep, whereas under anesthesia, brain waves are held in the same state for the length of the operation.
• Sleep is associated with a natural feeling of being well-rested upon waking, whereas coming out of anesthesia is not the same sensation.
• Sleep is associated with dreaming, which does not occur under full general anesthesia but can occur during lighter sedation.
• Sleep efficiency and REM sleep are suppressed on the first night after anesthesia in pediatric patients undergoing tonsillectomy.
• Anesthesia can cause sleep disturbances, especially in certain patient populations and types of surgery.
• Sleep disturbances may be influenced by pre-existing sleep disorders, inflammation, psychological and environmental factors, and pain perception due to regional wounds.
• Anesthesia can affect the postoperative sleep architecture and/or circadian rhythm.
• Anesthesia may have different effects on sleep in patients with pre-existing conditions such as autism spectrum disorder, Alzheimer's disease, or cerebellar malfunction.
• Anesthesia can cause a significant increase in REM sleep a few days after the procedure since REM sleep is inhibited during anesthesia.
• The type of anesthetic agent used may affect sleep architecture.

Sleep is a natural process, while anesthesia is drug-induced

Anesthesia, on the other hand, is a pharmacologically induced state of reversible unconsciousness, with hypnosis, analgesia, akinesia, and anxiolysis as its key features. It is achieved by the systemic administration of a combination of agents that produce a "balanced anesthesia." The nature of anesthetic narcosis is dose-dependent and agent-specific, and it exhibits a relative lack of nociceptive response and active suppression of motor and autonomic reflexes.

While sleep and anesthesia share some neurobiological features, they are distinct states with fundamental physiological differences. Anesthesia does not follow the cycling between REM and non-REM sleep seen in natural sleep. Instead, it involves cycling brain states with varying EEG readings. Sleep is actively generated in the brain, while anesthesia is induced pharmacologically and does not show the fluctuation and cycling seen in sleep.

The onset of sleep is regulated by neurotransmitter systems, particularly fast neurotransmitters like GABA and glutamate. Neurotransmitters like GABA and glutamate are also involved in anesthesia, but the specific mechanisms differ, with anesthesia often targeting specific molecules or brain regions.

Additionally, sleep and anesthesia have different effects on brain connectivity. Sleep is associated with periodic cycling between REM and non-REM sleep, with distinct EEG activity in each state. In contrast, anesthesia exhibits a more widespread disruption of brain connectivity, impairing information integration and processing. Anesthesia produces a signature EEG pattern of burst suppression, indicating more widespread disruption of thalamocortical connectivity.

Furthermore, sleep and anesthesia differ in their effects on nociceptive response, reflex suppression, autonomic nervous system response, and cognitive development. Sleep is essential for memory consolidation and cognitive development, while anesthesia exhibits neurotoxicity at the extremes of age and can cause postoperative cognitive dysfunction in the elderly.

Finally, sleep offset occurs rapidly, with intrinsic resistance to reinitiating sleep immediately after waking. In contrast, resumption of wakefulness from anesthesia can take much longer, and it is not simply a reversal of the induction process. Anesthesia also has iatrogenic side effects, such as postoperative nausea, cardiorespiratory depression, and immune function losses, which are not typically seen after natural sleep.

Sleep is necessary for health, while anesthesia is used for surgery

Sleep is a natural, endogenously generated process that is vital for health and involves the active suppression of consciousness by nuclei in the brainstem, diencephalon, and basal forebrain. It is regulated by a circadian clock that controls the timing of sleep and wakefulness across a 24-hour day and a homeostatic process that regulates sleep need and intensity based on the time spent awake or asleep. Sleep typically alternates between two distinct states: rapid eye movement (REM) sleep and non-rapid eye movement (NREM) sleep.

Anesthesia, on the other hand, is a pharmacologically induced reversible state of unconsciousness that shares some similarities with sleep but serves a different purpose. It is often administered before surgery to induce hypnosis, analgesia, akinesia, and anxiolysis. Anesthesia exhibits a more widespread disruption of brain connectivity than natural sleep, impairing information integration and processing. It also actively inhibits neural circuits in the brainstem and spinal cord, resulting in the suppression of reflex withdrawal from noxious stimuli and the loss of protective reflexes maintained during sleep, such as the cough and gag reflexes.

While sleep is necessary for health, anesthesia is used for surgery and other medical procedures to induce a controlled state of unconsciousness, analgesia, and immobility.

Sleep and anesthesia have different effects on memory

Sleep and Memory

Sleep is an endogenous process that involves the active suppression of consciousness by nuclei in the brainstem, diencephalon, and basal forebrain. It is vital for memory consolidation and cognitive development. Sleep has two distinct states: rapid eye movement (REM) sleep and non-rapid eye movement (NREM) sleep, with the brain and body slowing down during the latter.

Anesthesia and Memory

Anesthesia, on the other hand, is a pharmacologically induced reversible state of unconsciousness, amnesia, analgesia, and akinesia. It is achieved by administering a combination of agents that produce a balanced effect, and the specific nature of the anesthetic state depends on the dose and agent used.

Anesthesia suppresses memory formation, and the patient does not form any memories during this period. The amnesia associated with anesthesia is distinct from the memory consolidation function of sleep.

Differences in Brain Activity

The brain activity during sleep and anesthesia also differs. Sleep is regulated by neurotransmitter systems, with the transition from slow-wave sleep to REM sleep corresponding to a switch from delta waves to low-voltage, high-frequency EEG activity.

In contrast, anesthesia exhibits a more widespread disruption of brain connectivity, with a signature EEG pattern of burst suppression, which indicates more profound dampening of brain activity compared to sleep.

Effects on Cognitive Development

While sleep plays a crucial role in memory consolidation and cognitive development, anesthesia exhibits neurotoxicity at the extremes of age and can cause apoptosis and interfere with neurogenesis in neonates. Postoperative cognitive dysfunction is a common complication of general anesthesia in the elderly.

Sleep and anesthesia have different effects on the body's systems

Sleep and anesthesia are two entirely different conditions. While sleep is an endogenously generated process, anesthesia is a pharmacologically induced state of reversible unconsciousness. Sleep is actively generated in the brain and is dependent on homeostatic drive and circadian rhythms. On the other hand, anesthesia is dose-dependent and agent-specific, with the stages of anesthesia not showing the fluctuation and cycling seen in sleep.

Onset

The onset of sleep is regulated by a variety of neurotransmitter systems, with recent studies suggesting the involvement of fast neurotransmitters such as GABA and glutamate. The ease of sleep onset is also subject to environmental factors such as temperature, noise, light, and chemical stimulants. In contrast, anesthesia is a pharmacologically induced state, with the stages of anesthesia not usually showing the fluctuation and cycling seen in sleep.

Maintenance

During sleep, the brain moves between slow waves of non-rapid eye movement (NREM) sleep and the fast waves of REM sleep. Under general anesthesia, brain waves are held in the same state and remain there for the length of the operation.

Emergence

Sleep offset occurs rapidly in a matter of minutes, with an intrinsic resistance to reinitiating sleep immediately after waking. Conversely, resumption of wakefulness from general anesthesia can take much longer, and re-anesthetizing a patient can be achieved immediately after anesthetic emergence.

Reflex suppression and atonia

Sleep and anesthesia also differ in terms of immobility and reflex suppression. Sleep is characterized by the preservation of spinal cord reflex loops, while anesthesia is marked by the active inhibition of neural circuits in the brainstem and spinal cord, resulting in the suppression of reflex withdrawal from noxious stimuli.

Autonomic nervous system response

Another difference lies in the autonomic nervous system response. Sleep can be quickly reversed by stimulating somatosensory receptors or the cortex with noxious stimuli, whereas emergence from anesthesia is dependent on drug washout.

Cognitive development

While sleep plays a key role in memory consolidation and cognitive development, anesthesia exhibits neurotoxicity at the extremes of age, with the underlying mechanisms still poorly understood.

Frequently asked questions