Fitness Bands: Tracking Sleep, Understanding Rest

Sleep tracking devices have become increasingly popular in recent years, with many people turning to fitness bands and smartwatches to gain insights into their sleep patterns. While these devices do not directly measure sleep, they use a method called actigraphy to track movements and estimate sleep duration and quality. They can provide valuable data on sleep duration, quality, stages, and problems like sleep apnea. However, it's important to interpret the data with caution as these devices rely on movement rather than brain activity to determine sleep stages. They can be a useful tool for optimising your bedtime routine and understanding your sleep habits, but for exact data, a medical sleep study is necessary.

Actigraphy: A method to track movements to measure sleep

Actigraphy is a method of tracking movements to measure sleep. It involves the use of a device known as an actigraph, which is typically worn on the wrist like a watch, to track and record an individual's movements during sleep. The data collected by the actigraph is then translated by software into periods of sleep and wakefulness. Actigraphy is often used in sleep studies as it offers a convenient way to monitor sleep patterns outside of a laboratory setting. It is particularly useful for individuals with sleep disorders or disruptions as it allows them to be assessed in their natural sleep environment without the need for cumbersome equipment.

Actigraphy has been used in sleep research since the early 1990s and has gained popularity due to its affordability, convenience, and relatively high accuracy. It is considered generally accurate for tracking the sleep of healthy adults with normal sleep patterns. However, its accuracy decreases with more disrupted sleep patterns. Actigraphy is also useful for assessing daytime sleepiness and can be employed to evaluate insomnia, circadian rhythm disorders, and excessive sleepiness.

The actigraphy device can be worn 24/7, providing continuous data on an individual's sleep patterns and daytime activity. It is similar to a pedometer in that it can be worn around the waist to track wake-time activity and estimate calorie expenditure. Actigraphy devices also offer different sensitivity settings, allowing users to adjust the threshold for registering awake time. A higher threshold requires more significant movement to indicate wakefulness, potentially improving the accuracy of sleep tracking.

While actigraphy has its advantages, it is important to note that it does not measure brain activity, eye movements, muscle activity, or heart rhythm. Therefore, it should not be solely relied upon for the diagnosis of certain sleep disorders, and polysomnography (PSG) may still be necessary in some cases. PSG provides a more comprehensive assessment of sleep by measuring multiple physiological parameters, but it is more expensive and inconvenient for the patient.

PSG: Polysomnography is a lab-based sleep study method

Polysomnography, or PSG, is a lab-based sleep study method used to diagnose sleep disorders. It is a non-invasive, painless procedure that involves monitoring various physiological parameters during sleep. PSG is typically conducted in hospitals or sleep centres, where patients arrive in the evening to have their nighttime sleep patterns recorded and analysed.

During a PSG test, multiple parameters are measured and recorded. This includes brain waves, which are captured using electroencephalography (EEG), with a minimum of three channels dedicated to this. Eye movements are also monitored, with one or two channels dedicated to this, typically using electrooculography (EOG). Additionally, PSG measures heart rate and rhythm, breathing patterns, oxygen saturation levels in the blood, and leg movements. The minimum number of channels recorded in a polysomnogram is 12, requiring a minimum of 22 wire attachments to the patient.

One important objective of PSG is to determine the Respiratory Disturbance Index (RDI), which quantifies the number of apneas or hypopneas per hour of sleep. Apnea refers to the suspension of breathing caused by airway obstruction, while hypopnea is a milder form characterised by shallow breathing or low respiratory rates. By calculating the RDI, clinicians can assess the presence and severity of Obstructive Sleep Apnea (OSA).

PSG is also used to inform treatment plans for sleep disorders. For example, in the case of OSA, PSG can be used to determine the correct amount of pressure and the appropriate mask type and size for continuous positive airway pressure (CPAP) therapy. This is achieved through a "CPAP titration study," where the technician adjusts the airway pressure inside the mask until the patient's airway obstructions are eliminated.

Sleep quality: Fitness bands can measure sleep quality

While actigraphy is generally accurate enough to track sleep in healthy adults with "normal" sleep patterns, it is less accurate when sleep is disrupted. The more disrupted the sleep, the less accurate actigraphy will be at tracking it. Actigraphy devices generally have a high margin of error and either under- or overestimate time asleep. If you've tried one of these, you may have noticed that it thinks you're asleep when you lie still in bed, or it fails to realise you're awake when you start moving around.

Wearable sleep trackers often provide more than just sleep data. Many are fitness trackers that record physical activities day and night. Some of the best sleep-tracking technology is found in smartwatches. Most wearable sleep trackers are worn around the wrist and are actigraphy monitors that measure movement using built-in accelerometers. Using these readings, the tracker can determine if the wearer had a restless, fitful night, or if they slept peacefully and relatively still. They also track heart rate, another indicator of one's sleep state.

Advanced wearable sleep trackers go one step further by evaluating sleep quality based on the duration of different sleep cycle stages, as well as the sleeper's heart rate. Many will produce graphs or visual displays that pinpoint times of the night when the wearer slept exceptionally well or when their sleep was most disturbed. The Withings Steel HR Hybrid Smartwatch is an example of an advanced sleep tracker that monitors how long it takes wearers to fall asleep, how long they remain asleep, and whether or not they experience sleep interruptions. It also provides data for individual sleep stages and is ideal for fitness-minded people.

Heart rate: Sleep trackers can monitor heart rate

Heart rate monitoring is a common feature of sleep trackers. Sleep trackers with heart rate monitoring capabilities use infrared photoplethysmography sensors to track heart rate and respiration. The Oura Ring, for example, uses these sensors to track total sleep, time in bed, sleep efficiency, and resting heart rate. The Whoop 4.0 has also been praised for its accurate heart rate tracking capabilities.

Heart rate tracking is important for sleep monitoring as it helps to determine sleep quality. Sleep trackers can identify trends in sleep by monitoring heart rate and other metrics such as energy output, blood-oxygen level, body temperature, and movement. These devices can then provide advice on improving rest and fitness.

While sleep trackers can provide valuable insights, it is important to remember that they are not medical devices. Sleep tracking devices cannot perfectly analyze sleep or diagnose sleep disorders. If you have concerns about your sleep quality, it is recommended to consult a health practitioner.

Additionally, it is worth noting that sleep trackers rely primarily on movement to determine sleep patterns. As a result, they may not accurately distinguish between sleep stages, which are defined by brain activity rather than physical movement. Despite this limitation, sleep trackers can still provide a general guide to sleep time and efficiency, especially for individuals who generally sleep well.

In summary, heart rate monitoring is a valuable feature of sleep trackers that helps to assess sleep quality and identify trends. However, it is important to approach the data provided by these devices with a degree of skepticism and seek professional advice for any sleep-related concerns.

Sleep stages: Some trackers can provide data for individual sleep stages

Sleep trackers can be useful for people who want to gain insight into their sleep patterns. However, it is important to note that these devices do not directly measure sleep. Instead, they rely on detecting body movement and sometimes heart rate data to estimate sleep. As a result, they may not accurately differentiate between sleep stages, which are primarily defined by brain activity.

Some advanced sleep trackers, like the Bia Smart Sleep Mask, use brain-monitoring technology to track sleep stages. This mask uses Functional Near-Infrared Spectroscopy (fNIRS) to monitor brain activity and provide insights into the different stages of sleep. The mask also has features like neurofeedback techniques to guide the user to sleep and separate modes for evening sleep, napping, meditation, and jet lag adjustment.

The Muse S Headband Sleep Tracker is another example of a device that tracks sleep stages. It uses sensors to measure brain activity and determine the amount of time spent in each sleep stage. Additionally, it tracks movement, heart rate, and breathing, and this data is used in conjunction with a meditation app to enhance the user's sleep and meditation experience.

The Withings Sleep is a low-profile device that can be placed under a mattress to collect data on sleep cycles, heart rate, and breathing. It processes this data to generate reports and provide an overall sleep score.

While these advanced sleep trackers offer more detailed insights into sleep stages, it is important to remember that even the most advanced trackers may not accurately identify sleep stages due to the complex nature of sleep and the limitations of current technology.

Frequently asked questions