Sleep Trackers: How Do They Know When You're Asleep?

Sleep trackers have become increasingly popular as more and more people report sleep complaints. While they can collect a lot of information about sleep habits, they don't measure sleep directly. Sleep trackers use an algorithm to estimate how much time you spend asleep based on body movements and sometimes heart rate data. They can also record environmental factors like light and temperature, as well as lifestyle factors like caffeine intake and stress levels. The data from sleep trackers can be useful for helping you recognize patterns in your sleep habits and make improvements. However, it's important to note that they may not always be accurate and can cause unwanted anxiety for some users.

Sleep trackers measure sleep by tracking inactivity and body movements

Sleep trackers are popular devices that can help people understand their sleep habits and patterns. However, it is important to note that they do not directly measure sleep. Instead, they rely on tracking inactivity and body movements as a surrogate for estimating sleep.

Sleep trackers use various methods to track sleep, with the most common ones being wearable devices, such as smartwatches, rings, wristbands, and headbands. These devices use direct skin contact to measure heart rate and motion, providing insights into sleep and wake patterns. They utilise sensors and algorithms to detect body movements and estimate sleep duration and quality.

Wearable sleep trackers often incorporate heart rate monitoring, which can improve the accuracy of sleep measurement. Heart rate fluctuates during different sleep stages, and by tracking these changes, devices can better estimate the duration and quality of sleep. Additionally, some wearables use actigraphy, or wrist movement detection, to detect sleep patterns and sleep cycle stages.

Another type of sleep tracker is the below-mattress sensor, which gauges movement to determine when a person is asleep. These sensors can detect body movements and use algorithms to estimate sleep patterns. Smartphone apps are also available for sleep tracking, and they often use the phone's microphone or accelerometer technology to measure sleep. Some apps, like Sleep.com, utilise sonar technology to send silent signals into the sleep environment, which reflect back to the phone's microphone, allowing it to track breathing rate and body movement accurately.

While sleep trackers can provide valuable insights into sleep habits, they have limitations. They estimate sleep based on inactivity and body movements, which may not always be accurate, especially for people with insomnia who remain very still while trying to fall asleep. For precise data about sleep habits and disorders, medical sleep studies that monitor brain waves and other physiological parameters are necessary.

They can also measure heart rate and respiration

Sleep trackers are devices that can be worn on the wrist or clipped to a pillow to monitor sleep patterns. They do not directly measure sleep but instead use inactivity as a surrogate for estimating sleep. Sleep trackers can measure the number of times your sleep was interrupted, the time taken to fall asleep, and the total sleep duration. They can also gauge sleep cycles, including REM and non-REM phases.

Sleep trackers can also measure heart rate and respiration. The Oura Ring Gen3, for example, shines infrared light beams through the skin and uses sensors to measure respiratory rate, heart rate, heart rate variability, blood oxygen levels, and body temperature. The data is then synthesised to provide three daily scores: Sleep, Activity, and Readiness. The Withings ScanWatch 2 also provides a sleep score and measures respiratory rate, heart rate, temperature, and blood oxygen levels. Smartwatches are also equipped with heart rate monitors and SpO2 trackers, which can be used to measure sleep patterns.

Heart rate fluctuates during different sleep stages, so tracking heart rate data can help monitor sleep cycles more closely. Heart rate data can also help distinguish between sleep and wakefulness, especially in people with insomnia who remain very still while trying to fall asleep. However, the accuracy of sleep trackers that measure heart rate is uncertain due to limited research and differences between devices. For example, one study showed that two consumer devices underestimated deep sleep by as much as 46 minutes.

They don't measure sleep directly, but estimate it

Sleep trackers don't measure sleep directly but instead estimate it. They often measure inactivity as a surrogate for estimating sleep. They collect a lot of information about your slumber habits, such as tracking the time you're inactive, and can record when you fall asleep and when you stir in the morning. They can also detect interrupted sleep, letting you know when you're tossing and turning or waking during the night.

Sleep trackers use an algorithm to estimate how much time you spent asleep based on body movements. They can also use direct skin contact to discern your heart rate and motion, getting a sense of your sleep and wake patterns. Some trackers also use a microphone to capture noise from the room or your body. If you're moving frequently and not sleeping well, some trackers will note that. A microphone can also measure your respiration, detecting snoring, sleep apnea, and how often you wake up during the night.

Sleep trackers can also come in the form of a smartphone app. The Sleep.com app, for example, uses sonar to assess both movement and breathing rate – a combination that provides an accurate picture of your sleep. It sends silent signals into your sleep environment, and when these sound waves reflect into your microphone, its advanced algorithm interprets their shape and movement, measuring your breathing rate and tracking your body movement.

Some sleep trackers also estimate REM sleep in addition to deep and light sleep stages by measuring heart rate. Heart rate and respiration rates are known to vary during sleep, but they have a close relationship with each sleep stage since the autonomic nervous system significantly affects both.

They can help you recognise patterns in your sleep habits

Sleep trackers can help you recognise patterns in your sleep habits. They can record the time you fall asleep and when you wake up, helping you determine the number of hours you slept. They can also detect interrupted sleep, letting you know when you're tossing and turning or waking during the night. Some trackers also record the environment of your sleep, such as the amount of light or temperature in your bedroom. This information can help you identify factors that may be affecting your sleep quality.

Additionally, some sleep trackers allow you to input lifestyle factors, such as your caffeine intake, physical activity, and stress levels, which can help you understand how these factors influence your sleep. While sleep trackers don't directly measure sleep, they estimate sleep by tracking body movements and, in some cases, heart rate data. The data collected by sleep trackers can provide insights into your sleep habits and help you make informed decisions to improve your sleep quality.

Smartwatches, for example, have built-in sleep trackers that utilise sensors to monitor your sleep cycles and patterns. These devices can track your movements and heart rate changes throughout the different stages of sleep. By analysing this data, smartwatches can provide insights into your sleep habits and help you identify patterns that promote or disrupt your sleep quality.

It's important to note that sleep trackers may not be 100% accurate in measuring sleep, and their accuracy can vary depending on individual factors and device specifications. However, they can still provide valuable insights into your sleep habits, helping you recognise patterns and make adjustments for improved sleep quality.

They can be inaccurate and cause anxiety

Sleep trackers can be inaccurate and cause anxiety for some users. They do not measure sleep directly and instead rely on measuring inactivity and body movements as a surrogate for estimating sleep. This means that they often make guesstimates about the user's sleep and may be inaccurate in their readings.

Research has found that compared to polysomnography tests—which are considered the gold standard for diagnosing sleep disorders—sleep trackers are only accurate 78% of the time when identifying sleep versus wakefulness. This accuracy drops to around 38% when estimating how long it took participants to fall asleep. Polysomnography tests track brain waves, heart rate, blood oxygen levels, breathing, body movements, and eye movements during sleep, providing a much more comprehensive analysis of sleep patterns.

Additionally, sleep trackers may cause unwanted anxiety for some users. Several doctors and sleep specialists have warned that tracking sleep can increase anxiety about insomnia and do more harm than good. This condition has been termed "orthosomnia" by researchers, referring to an unhealthy obsession with achieving perfect sleep. The constant monitoring and analysis of sleep data can lead to excessive preoccupation with sleep goals, causing bedtime anxiety and potentially exacerbating symptoms of insomnia.

The inaccuracy of sleep trackers can also contribute to anxiety. Users may become concerned about their sleep patterns based on unverified scores, even for variables like the amount of deep sleep, which can vary significantly between individuals. Furthermore, some trackers may give the impression that they can diagnose medical conditions without having the necessary data or approval to support those claims.

While sleep trackers can provide insights into sleep patterns, it is important to approach them with caution. Users should be aware of the potential limitations and inaccuracies of the data presented and avoid developing an unhealthy obsession with achieving perfect sleep. If you have concerns about your sleep quality, it is advisable to consult a health practitioner rather than solely relying on sleep tracker data.

Frequently asked questions