Mi Band 5: Sleep Tracking And More

Xiaomi's Mi Band 5 is a wearable device that offers sleep-tracking features. It uses body movement, heart rate, and other factors like temperature, noise, and light to analyze sleep patterns and identify sleep during the daytime if the user sleeps for a long time. While some users have reported issues with the accuracy of the sleep tracking, others have found it to be a useful tool to understand their sleeping habits better. The device also has additional features like an accelerometer, gyroscope, and PPG biosensors.

Mi Band 5's sleep tracking accuracy

The Xiaomi Mi Band 5 is a budget fitness tracker that offers sleep tracking capabilities. While it has been advertised as having improved sleep monitoring accuracy by 40% compared to its predecessor, the Mi Band 4, the actual accuracy of the sleep tracking feature has been questioned by some users.

One of the main concerns regarding the Mi Band 5's sleep tracking accuracy is its ability to track naps. Some users have reported that the device does not record short naps, while others have found that it tracks naps longer than 20 minutes accurately. There have also been instances where the band has confused sleep and relaxation, leading to an overestimation of total sleep time and an inaccurate calculation of deep sleep percentage.

The Mi Band 5's sleep tracking feature relies on heart rate and movement patterns to estimate sleep stages, such as deep sleep, REM sleep, and light sleep. While this method provides a rough guide, it may not be as accurate as specialised sleep tracking devices. For example, one user compared the Mi Band 5's sleep data with that of a Fitbit and Withings device and found significant discrepancies.

However, it is important to note that the Mi Band 5's sleep tracking accuracy can be improved by ensuring a snug fit on the user's wrist and reducing hair interference with the sensor. Additionally, the device allows users to set an automatic sleep detection feature, which can be enhanced by setting an alarm.

In conclusion, while the Mi Band 5 offers sleep tracking capabilities and has been advertised as having improved accuracy, user experiences vary. The device may be suitable for those seeking a rough guide to their sleep patterns, but for more accurate data, specialised sleep tracking devices or methods may be preferred.

How Mi Band 5 tracks sleep

The Mi Band 5 uses body movements to monitor the sleep cycle, and the phone's algorithm will generate a report of your sleep irregularities. It has three prominent biosensors to detect your sleep: an accelerator, gyroscope, and PPG. The working principle is the same in all these cases: they sense irregular motions, and the rest period is identified as sleep. The band worn on the wrist converts these wrist movements into sleep patterns. It concludes that having zero body movements is a state of sleep, and rigorous movements are a state of awakening from sleep, thereby helping deduce sleep patterns.

The Mi Band 5 does support sleep tracking of three types: light sleep, deep sleep, and Rapid Eye Movement (REM). Light sleep is a transitional stage between being awake and asleep. You can be woken up easily during light sleep, and body movements are minimal. When the body movements and heart rate slow down, it detects the phase of light sleep. Deep sleep occurs after light sleep; it is a state of complete unconsciousness. During this stage, the heart rate and blood pressure drastically slow down. REM sleep happens when you are coming out of sleep and is when dreams occur. It helps restore mental health.

The Mi Band 5 can also track naps, which appear as a subsection of sleep in the app. However, it seems that the naps have to be 20 minutes or longer for them to be recorded. Some users have also reported that the Mi Band 5 does not accurately track their sleep, with one user stating that their sleep was not recorded when they slept during the day. Another user reported that their sleep was not recorded when they woke up in the middle of the night.

Mi Band 5's ability to track naps

The Xiaomi Mi Band 5 can track naps, but there are some conditions. Some users have reported that the band has to be tightened for accurate results. The band also needs to be worn on the wrist to track sleep, as it relies on tracking body movements and heart rate to determine sleep patterns. Some users have reported that the band only tracks naps that are 20 minutes or longer.

The Mi Band 5 has been reported to have poor sleep tracking accuracy. It cannot recognize different stages of sleep and has been known to confuse daytime naps with sleep. It also does not always record sleep accurately, with some users reporting that it only recorded 5 hours and 11 minutes of sleep when they had slept for closer to 8 hours. It also does not seem to track sleep that is split up throughout the day very well. For example, if a user sleeps for 3 and a half hours, wakes up for a few hours, then sleeps for another 3 to 3 and a half hours, the band will only record the first part of sleep.

The band has three biosensors to detect sleep: an accelerator, gyroscope, and PPG. It also has an accelerometer and heart sensor to track light sleep. The band detects slight body movements and gravity changes, as well as changes in heart rate and blood pressure, to determine sleep patterns.

Comparison with other sleep trackers

The Mi Band 5 is a cheap fitness tracker that offers 24-hour sleep tracking. However, it is not the most in-depth sleep-tracking solution on the market. It uses a built-in accelerometer to detect motion and a heart rate sensor to estimate when you fall asleep. It also has blood oxygen sensors to monitor breathing quality.

Some users have reported issues with the Mi Band 5's sleep-tracking feature. For example, it may not record naps or daytime sleep, and it may not accurately track sleep when the user gets up in the middle of the night. It also does not use any specialised equipment for sleep tracking, so it may not be suitable for those seeking a more precise or medical-grade device.

Compared to other sleep trackers, the Mi Band 5 offers a basic sleep-tracking solution. While it can provide insights into sleep duration and sleep and wake times, it may not be as accurate as other devices in recognising sleep stages. However, for the price, it is a solid overall fitness tracker, especially when compared to other trackers in a similar price range, such as the Fitbit Inspire 2.

The Fitbit Inspire 2 is one of the closest competitors to the Mi Band 5 in terms of price and features. One key advantage of the Inspire 2 is that it offers new users a one-year subscription to Fitbit Premium, which may provide additional value. Other pricier devices, such as the Fitbit Sense 2, may also offer better apps and easier access to health data.

In summary, while the Mi Band 5 may not be the most advanced sleep tracker on the market, it offers a good balance of features and affordability. For those seeking a basic understanding of their sleep patterns, the Mi Band 5 may be a suitable option. However, for more in-depth sleep analysis, other trackers on the market may provide a more comprehensive solution.

User experience and reviews

The Xiaomi Mi Band 5 is a fitness tracker that offers 24/7 activity and sleep tracking. While it has been praised for its exceptional value for money, some users have criticised its sleep-tracking capabilities.

Some users have reported that the Mi Band 5 accurately tracks their sleep, including daytime naps. However, others have experienced issues with the device's sleep-tracking function, noting that it fails to record their sleep accurately, particularly when they sleep late or take short naps. For example, one user reported that the device only recorded 5 hours and 11 minutes of sleep when they believed they had slept for around 8 hours, due to a toilet break during the night.

The Mi Band 5 has a feature that allows it to learn your sleep patterns and start tracking automatically, especially if you have an alarm set. Users have noted that the band's tightness on the arm can impact the accuracy of sleep tracking, with a loose band potentially leading to strange results. Shaving arm hair and ensuring the band is tight enough have been suggested as ways to improve the accuracy of sleep tracking.

The device has also been known to occasionally confuse sleep patterns, such as when a user takes multiple naps in a day. In terms of competition, the Fitbit Inspire 2 is considered the closest rival to the Mi Band 5 in terms of price and features, although it is a more serious investment at around $100. The Mi Band 5's newer sibling, the Mi Band 6, addresses some of the shortcomings of the Mi Band 5 but comes at a higher price point of around $55.

Overall, while the Mi Band 5 has received some criticism for its sleep-tracking capabilities, it is generally praised for offering exceptional value for money in the fitness tracking market.

Frequently asked questions